Uprated DSG Clutches

DeckedS3

Registered User
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
951
Reaction score
370
Points
63
Location
South East
Is anyone on here running uprated DSG clutches?

If so, what ones and what are they like?

Has anyone heard of Dodson clutchpacks? Any good?
 
You need to speak to Stefan on VAGOC,if you haven't already.

I think he's tried both SSP and HPA.
 
You need to speak to Stefan on VAGOC,if you haven't already.

I think he's tried both SSP and HPA.

I haven't, but I don't want to use SSP and HPA is very expensive that doesn't need to be. But as they are first to market a bullet proof option they have a huge price tag. More options are being released but I want to see if anyone has used anything else.

To be specific, I'm hoping for someone to say they have a Dodson clutch pack. There is also another option "coming soon" but I want it "sooner" :footy:
 
I haven't, but I don't want to use SSP and HPA is very expensive that doesn't need to be. But as they are first to market a bullet proof option they have a huge price tag. More options are being released but I want to see if anyone has used anything else.

To be specific, I'm hoping for someone to say they have a Dodson clutch pack. There is also another option "coming soon" but I want it "sooner" :footy:

I can't remember for sure,but I think Stefan had some issues with the SSP pack,and went for the HPA,but you'd need to ask him.
I thought you might be hoping someone said the Dodson was OK!....good luck.
 
I've read a few times that the HPA clutches don't last long. I have no idea why....
 
I've read a few times that the HPA clutches don't last long. I have no idea why....


Can't help you there,I'm afraid,but Stefan may be able to.
 
After much research I've decided to go with Dodson. The deciding factor was down to how the discs function differently to OEM clutch packs. Rather than slipping by design when power exceeds X torque value, the Dodson's grip harder and you don't have to apply more clutch pressure which is a huge plus for me. So I've got about 6 weeks to kill the OEM clutch pack until the Dodson's go in!
 
  • Like
Reactions: S3_Mat, Mario8P and S3Alex
Hi.
Where do you get this from?
Any links?....
 
There are quite a few installers in the UK now, but I've decided to go with Statller in Sheffield as they seem to be the most familiar with the 02E gearboxes. The easiest way to check them out is on Facebook.
 
Cool, what are the results? How much power and oil pressure?

Just posted this on another forum:

Hi Guys, I’m pretty surprised the name of TVS-engineering / DSGdokter.nl is not mentioned. To give you an idea: They do 1.500 DSG’s per year and stock over 1.000 DSG gearboxes!!


They offer DQ250 software for stock clutch with 550Nm (16-17bar), DQ250 raceclutches and DQ500 convert kits, DQ500 raceclutch, DQ500 software and even for the DQ200 software which does over 400Nm’s(New A3 1.8 TSI 180hp).
I study myself on HAN Arnhem, designing a DSG testing machine for them. I now do a project for this company as some other students. (ps. hope to have the machine ready for Rematec show in Amsterdam june-2015.

In the office I hear them talking daily about this subject. Some first-hand info that I learned and experienced, and you maybe might want to know :

It’s all about software. You should not pick Software brand A and clutch Brand B. The friction coefficient of the friction material is crucial. SSP runs hard plates. When you install them you will see lots of slip. The plates are too hard. You must perform a very long drive in period so the Mechatronic can correct all adaption values. I’m 101% sure TVS sells DSG software specially for these SSP clutches to avoid a 1000 mile drive-in period. They do not sell SSP themselves cause the effective extra torque capability is minor.

Dodson: No idea I’m looking for results, that’s how I found this topic.
For SSP you find old topics with satisfied customers but some topics end up in drama. Hope this will not be the case with Dodson. But It surprises me that I do not see Dodson offering Software. If you know how DSG software works(and I know quite a lot about this) it’s theoretical impossible to make a perfect combination. The software is quite self-learning and that helps allot. But values like friction coefficient should be customized in the software to make a professional product. There are over 300 maps and variables. I helped with some mapping changing like 50 maps and variables like oil-cooling back shift latency etc.
Believe me, the top-brands you guys are talking about, alter just a few maps, mainly the torque limiter. Harsh but true. It’s all about the base-map they use ;) I cannot tell too much cause I will get my *** kicked. But to give you an example: A Golf6R20 software file can handle more torque then a Golf5R32 file.

The link from the 750whp car is awesome, but I’m surprised nobody is saying the clutch barely holds. Listen to the exhaust sound. The shifts are super slow the clutch slips way too much. If you would shift not in rev-limiter but in max TQ rpm range (say 5000rpm) there will be a chance clutch will slip and burn away in seconds. This gearbox will not hold for long and will get overheated I think. Btw, a DQ250 gearset is way too weak for this power to be durable. 600Nm max.

Also there is no torque reduction on shift. I learned this just a week ago. When you perform a Launch control the engine power is not cut at a full throttle shift. It’s the “prr” noise which you normally hear. Listen carefully!
TVS has 100% unique software for this. I have been sitting in a TT-RS APR stage III+ with extra mods. The stock clutch could not hold power with a Launch control, just like in the movie above. They altered the LC modus and know again you hear the “prr” noise on shift, just like in normal D or S driving. And know the stock clutch could handle all power (700Nm I thought).

I have also seen a Golf6R APR stage III+ with stock clutches. I was in the car making datalogs. They sell the software to many APR dealers all over the world cause the APR DSG software is extremely poor(which is already mentioned here). APR dealers must know this??

Increase oil pressure:
This is the subject I’m fighting on daily J People think that oil pressure is increased, but that’s not how it works. The oil pressure is depending on the power that is put on the clutch.

The clutch ALWAYS slips, for about 1%. So if the input shaft does 3000rpm, the output shaft does 2770rpm. The slips is regulated at ultra high speeds. It gives comfort and reduces gearboxwear, and reduces fuel consumption cause the oil pomp does not have to work so hard to close the clutch, only when needed on full throttle. You can find this info in VW-DSG brochures.

So if you tune your engine, you oil pressure will auto-increase. So think: If you change the friction material, you will screw up the PID-regulator calculating the needed oil pressure.
The highest oil pressure you can get is 16-17bar. Simply because the Mechatronic clutch section cannot supply more pressure. Then you have to make mechanical modification first. On some forums you read people claiming to have like 20bar, but If you ask for VCDS datalogs of measuring block 011&012 nobody replies, maybe someone of you guys have good datalogs?

HGP clutches work quite well cause they use the factory friction material, and increase the amount of plates. After installation the gearbox can be quite rough, and noisy, will get better after a while. TVS re-tunes HPA/HGP/MTM cars allot. The engine power is way lower then listed on their website. I remember a Golf V R32 GT35 HGP doing 411hp instead of the 490hp. They re-mapped the engine, power increased(cannot remember check their facebook +/-450hp)) , and DSG could not hold anymore. It had the 7-plate HGP clutch. They put in new DSG software and the clutch holds. The HGP/HPA clutch is fine and almost identical to the TVS clutch, TVS changes not just the plates but also the housing, and that’s what it is all about ;)

Admin sorry I hope this is not too much advertisement in your eyes, it’s my true firsthand experience and hopefully helps people understanding this complex subject.

Well enough for now, maybe more info if I have time but think not due deadline. Another Student is working on a new DSGdokter.nl website with all info listed. Check their facebook for now!
In short there will also be a DSG community forum online with all info about DSG-tuning. And my test-machine will be shown off there as well I hope J
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pergan, scott25rsq3sb, Alex_Wil and 7 others
Holy sh...t. Did anyone read the above post???
I am the first to signe up for this sw...
How can I get it? Have been searching for a company that knows the DSG an this looks promising.
Can I get in contact with you or the company's?
Please send me a PM and I'll give you my email address...

I am running APR DSG sw now with there k04 ECU sw. Do I need to tel you my experience? No.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DeckedS3
I've interested too, I may hold off getting the Dodson clutches.... (booked in for Thursday too)
 
I have sent an email to DSG-Dokter.nl
Hope to get a reply tomorrow.
 
Wow!! Some decent information you got there mate! I am in too! Would like to hear more.
 
From what I understand, with the APR gearbox software tune, you can run stage 3 on OEM clutches.
 
Evening.
Got a reply from TVS-Engineering / DSG-dotter.nl

********
We have had loads of emails, we will try to contact you asap.
You can also call tomorrow if you would prefer that.
********
LOL seem it's not just me that sent them an email yesterday. hehe
I'll call them tomorrow an report back.
 
Evening.
Got a reply from TVS-Engineering / DSG-dotter.nl

********
We have had loads of emails, we will try to contact you asap.
You can also call tomorrow if you would prefer that.
********
LOL seem it's not just me that sent them an email yesterday. hehe
I'll call them tomorrow an report back.
LOL I emailed them. They forwarded me to a dealer in Israel
 
LOL I emailed them. They forwarded me to a dealer in Israel

Mario8P are you from Israel?
There is actually one person I know there who is a Tuning sw developer. His sw is used around the world by most tuning company's... Maybe you know him?
 
Mario8P are you from Israel?
There is actually one person I know there who is a Tuning sw developer. His sw is used around the world by most tuning company's... Maybe you know him?
No mate am located in Amman-Jordan. Israel is very close to us. But it's impossible for us to go there (politics)
 
I had a chat with them today. Very, very knowledgeable team and seem to do a lot of work for the major players in the tuning game and customers of high powered dsg cars when things go wrong. Worryingly, alarm bells started ringing when they gave me an overview of my APR dsg stage 2 file. I've always liked the remapped box and thought the gear changes felt ok when 3/4 throttle but it started to slur after this (as you've probably seen in some of my vids). APR won't acknowledge this and say it's all down to clutch slip. But as I have a new clutch and I know of others running more power with custom maps I was finding this hard to believe.

Due to work commitments I can't get over there anytime soon, but that also means my clutch install has been delayed (could be a blessing in disguise). I'm going to give them another call to confirm but from initial discussions they can do anything you want.... I went over my requirements with them and they've suggested a custom file with all the usual tricks but with guaranteed, faster, crisp gear changes and more clutch pressure (which is what I think I've needed all along, but all the tuners I've spoken to here have different opinions).

Anyone thinking about this should give them a call. I spoke to someone briefly who answered the phone, not sure who he was but knew what I was talking about and passed me onto Ronald for more detail. I would suggest speaking with him.

For a good reference, if anyone knows jaybyme with the TTRS running 700bhp, he's also running their software, as well as Harding performance (Australian tuning company specialising in APR products) I always found it strange that they didn't use APRs software, now I know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: grchmason and Mario8P
Any clue If they offer remote flashing by any chance?
 
Wow. The card hous is going to fall.
How come we newer heard about them before? I thought HPA/HGP Turbo was the no 1 in DSG flashing.
Then the rest with there own sw like APR, Revo, Giac, Unitronic, Bluefin, Custom-Code + other small individual tuning companies. Boy was I wrong.

Even I do not know mutch from this new player (new in the form of info here) I think this cold be the choice to go.
I will call Ronald today and report back emediatly. Let's hope they offer a loaner/ DIY flashing tool and are able to offer spsific sw files from info on the car setup and wishes from me.

I am super exited now. I have really looked at DSG sw for more than three years now.

@DeckedS3 I am running APR ECU (k04 turbo w/3bar MAP) and TCU sw matced for the K04 kit.
It's working for me but it's far from perfect. On the tracks it works ok with no slip for me at least (I hope) But DD it's clunking. I feel that on 2/4 throttle the clutch engaging is not synced correctly. For me it feels that the sw rushes to put in next gear without releasing the othe used.

From my info there is a UK company writing the DSG sw. For APR. (I can't confirm 100%) and they have less experience with the DSG.

I have also been in contact with AutoGraph Cars for custom sw after reading good reviews from other. This company sadly vent bankrupt before I got the chance to get the flashing cable/tool to work. I have been trying to lift all stones to have this don well.

I am crossing my fingers now.
 
They actually told me they worked on HGP cars (fixed them) and possibly worked with HGP. I must admit I'd been on their website but without being recommended or have some info about them I didn't do any more research. I was also told, they've had big tuners contact them asking for training on how to write code for DSG boxes..... That says it all imo.
 
Can the OEM dsg clutches not take much torque then?
 
Can the OEM dsg clutches not take much torque then?

It depends... Stock file, no it cant as the box restricts torque. But the box is capable of more with a DSG map. Don't worry too much as it can handle stage 2+ power no problem.
 
If you want a custom DSG remap either for std clutches or an uprated clutch talk to mrctuning in Banbury UK. I wanted launch control without having to press any buttons and be in sport mode etc... and they delivered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mark A Greenwood
Wow. The card hous is going to fall.
How come we newer heard about them before? I thought HPA/HGP Turbo was the no 1 in DSG flashing.
Then the rest with there own sw like APR, Revo, Giac, Unitronic, Bluefin, Custom-Code + other small individual tuning companies. Boy was I wrong.

Even I do not know mutch from this new player (new in the form of info here) I think this cold be the choice to go.
I will call Ronald today and report back emediatly. Let's hope they offer a loaner/ DIY flashing tool and are able to offer spsific sw files from info on the car setup and wishes from me.

I am super exited now. I have really looked at DSG sw for more than three years now.

@DeckedS3 I am running APR ECU (k04 turbo w/3bar MAP) and TCU sw matced for the K04 kit.
It's working for me but it's far from perfect. On the tracks it works ok with no slip for me at least (I hope) But DD it's clunking. I feel that on 2/4 throttle the clutch engaging is not synced correctly. For me it feels that the sw rushes to put in next gear without releasing the othe used.

From my info there is a UK company writing the DSG sw. For APR. (I can't confirm 100%) and they have less experience with the DSG.

I have also been in contact with AutoGraph Cars for custom sw after reading good reviews from other. This company sadly vent bankrupt before I got the chance to get the flashing cable/tool to work. I have been trying to lift all stones to have this don well.

I am crossing my fingers now.
Hey mate. Autograph cars (Andrew) is a forum vendor here, and i have contacted him a while ago, October 2014 when I wanted a custom tune for my s3. He was a great guy to talk to. But at the end I lousy contact as he never replied back to me when I asked for their flashing cable price including shipping charges.

I also saw him online yesterday. Unless your talking about other company
 
Hey mate. Autograph cars (Andrew) is a forum vendor here, and i have contacted him a while ago, October 2014 when I wanted a custom tune for my s3. He was a great guy to talk to. But at the end I lousy contact as he never replied back to me when I asked for their flashing cable price including shipping charges.

I also saw him online yesterday. Unless your talking about other company

This is my experience to. Andrew is a great guy to deal with if your able to get Him on the phone. Not a easy task.

I bought a DSG flashing tool from him that did not work. And after 6 month of waiting the buissenes closed down. No warnings. I had to trace down the producer of the tool and software by my self. Not sure how much time and money I invested into this. I ended up in Israel with the company Freiling Raceing who produces the DSG tooling and sw for a lot of the tuning companies around the world. He helped me extract my stock DSG sw and promised me a fix for the sw. It's been a year now and only empty promises. Sadly I have given up for this to happens and Andrew can't help me with a sw tune for my DSG. It's a ****** buissenes
My recommendation is. Do NOT buy anything like tools/cable before you get proof of it working. I am sorry to say this because it felt right in the beginning. Sorry Andrew in case you read this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mario8P
I talked to Ronald today. What a nice and service minded guy he is. He could confirm all my problems with the APR DSG tune/sw. And also other brands. He also told me that the big tuning players (not mentioning the names) wanted to buy there sw. But in the end they ended up just with copying parts of there sw string. This is why there is problems. The new sw is read protected after there sw is loaded/flashed info the TCU. Not even VW/Audi can do anything after this is done by TVS-Enginering.
Ronald told me the stock DQ250 box can handle safely 480Nm of torque. With special sw it can handle 500Nm but then shift can get a bit rough and a custom logging and tuning is needed in special cases. When more torque is applied more clutch/friction rings are needed for safe operation.
Hi gave me some prices but do not remember all of it.
Regarding flashing tool they offered me a loaner tool if I could accept a big deposit witch I have accepted. Just need to agree on what to get.

Regarding LC. The problem is heat. And to over come this you also need more clutch plates/rings.

Last he told me that all APR dealers in Netherlands are using there DSG sw. This says it all. I think we have a winner.

If you would like a complete DSG upgrade with new clutch, LSD and sw They need the car 3-4days. The car will then be tested and logged and fine tuned for best results. Or you can send the complete box to them and use off the shelf sw.

Hope this makes it interested for others.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mario8P
I talked to Ronald today. What a nice and service minded guy he is. He could confirm all my problems with the APR DSG tune/sw. And also other brands. He also told me that the big tuning players (not mentioning the names) wanted to but there sw ended up just with copying parts of there sw string. This is why there is problems. The new sw is read protected after there sw is loaded/flashed info the TCU. Not even VW/Audi can do anything after this is done by TVS-Enginering.
Ronald told me the stock DQ250 box can handle safely 480Nm of torque. With special sw it can handle 500Nm but then shift can get a bit rough and a custom logging and tuning is needed in special cases. When more torque is applied more clutch/friction rings are needed for safe operation.
Hi gave me some prices but do not remember all of it.
Regarding flashing tool they offered me a loaner tool if I could accept a big deposit witch I have accepted. Just need to agree on what to get.

Regarding LC. The problem is heat. And to over come this you also need more clutch plates/rings.

Last he told me that all APR dealers in Netherlands are using there DSG sw. This says it all. I think we have a winner.

If you would like a complete DSG upgrade with new clutch, LSD and sw They need the car 3-4days. The car will then be tested and logged and fine tuned for best results. Or you can send the complete box to them and use of the shelf sw.

Hope this makes it interested for others.
Thanks for sharing mate.
May intrude and ask how much did they ask for the DSG tune and whats the deposit amount they asked?

They told me to get in contact with PITSTOP garage in Israel as they are dealers for them. PITSTOP is also a APR dealer. I sent them a message on FB hope they'll respond. As Ronald didn't offer to lend a flashing tool.
He seems like a very busy guy judging from his email replies
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: A3SBQ
Thanks for sharing mate.
May intrude and ask how much did they ask for the DSG tune and whats the deposit amount they asked?

I do not want to say anything wrong or give fals info. But for me the deposit was €1500 + all shipping coast with tracking and insurance and additionally €1000 for the sw. If I wanted other options this is extra.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mario8P
I do not want to say anything wrong or give fals info. But for me the deposit was €1500 + all shipping coast with tracking and insurance and additionally €1000 for the sw. If I wanted other options this is extra.
Thanks for sharing mate

ouch isn't that a bit to steep for a TCU flash?

Anyway best of luck buddy and please do keep us posted.
 
Thanks for sharing mate

ouch isn't that a bit to steep for a TCU flash?

Anyway best of luck buddy and please do keep us posted.

Yes it's a lot of money but if it works it's worth it. I am on that point where no other option is possible. Here in Norway we do not have any big players doing DSG. So I need to do it my self by paying the deposit on there loaner cable. I think I'll try the sw for my turbo setup (APR K04) and then do clutches and LSD next.
 
He game me the same price but I'm going to drive over and get a custom tune setup. It's the same price I paid for the APR and now they've explained it to me I realise it was a total waste of money. Everything he said made sense.
If I need to return for a clutch at a later stage I'm happy to do that, but I'd rather try the software route first.
So glad the student came onto the forums and commented.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mario8P and A3SBQ

Similar threads

Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
24
Views
2K
Replies
18
Views
2K