What's a good Single Malt Scotch Whiskey

ImolaS4

Registered User
Joined
Mar 24, 2004
Messages
275
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
USA
Looking for something over 15 years old.
Planning a cigar party for a group of guys and need a few good suggestions.

Bear in mind, I'm in the States and I'll need to be able to find it here.

TIA
 
Highland Park (Made in Orkney) the best I've tried.
 
[ QUOTE ]
RogueElement said:
Highland Park (Made in Orkney) the best I've tried.

[/ QUOTE ]
Ooooo... I already have that one on a shelf! /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif
 
<PEDANT_HAT>

There are no good Scottish Whiskeys

There are plenty of good Scottish Whiskys though

</PEDANT_HAT>
 
Yeah... /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/blush.gif
I realized I spelled it wrong after it was too late.

Leave it to a purist to correct me! /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/tongue_out.gif

By the way: You're just as mistaken to call it "Scottish".

It's called Scotch Whisky.

So.... <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/[censored].gif" alt="" /> Hehe /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/goofy.gif
 
<PEDANT_HAT>

Sorry mate nothing wrong with saying Scottish Whisky. I know Yanks like to call it Scotch and it is referred to as Scotch Whisky but it is Scottish and it is Whisky.

2/10 for effort should try harder in future.

</PEDANT_HAT>

 
Funny thing is....
All the bottles say "Single Malt Scotch Whisky"
and the books I have on the subject say "Scotch Whisky". These Scottish authors take great pains to explain that the person is a Scots, anything made in or from Scotland is Scottish, but the whisky is spelled without the "e" and is referred to as Scotch.

To quote one author (a Scotsman), "The Scotsman wears a Scottish kilt whilst he drinks a dram of Scotch."

Lastly... From the Oxford Advanced Learners Dictionary :
Scottish / Scots / Scotch / Scot
>>The adjective Scottish is the most general word used to describe the people and things of Scotland, while Scots is only used to describe its people, its law and especially it language: Scottish dancing; the new Scottish parliament; a well-known Scots poet; a slight Scots accent.
>>The adjective Scotch is now mainly used in fixed expressions such as Scotch whisky and Scotch broth and sounds old-fashioned or insulting if it is used in any other way.
>>The noun Scotch means whisky, and the noun Scots refers to a language spoken in Scotland, closely related to English. A person who comes from Scotland is a Scot: The Scots won their match against England.
 
Anyway garethj:

Did you have a recommendation or did you want to continue this mini-diatribe?
 
Glenmorangie (10 years) or Chivas Regal, Glenfidich is also a good one. None of them are over 15 yrs but worth a try
 
[ QUOTE ]
Andy bS3 said:
Glenmorangie (10 years) or Chivas Regal, Glenfidich is also a good one. None of them are over 15 yrs but worth a try

[/ QUOTE ]
Isn't Chivas a blended?

I have both of the "glens" already. They have a bit of a bite, in my opinion.
 
Apologies, Chivas is a blended whisky

You could try looking at http://www.royalmilewhiskies.com/
This shop stocks everything and gives you a decent description of most Scottish whiskies, they do ship to the USA but it aint cheap.
What about a wee dram of Dalmore 62 yr old £25,000 a bottle /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/beerchug.gif
 
You absolutely cannot go wrong with an Ardbeg 17 year old. It has all of the flavours, but remains smooth and very drinkable, unlike some cheaper, newer malts....
 
[ QUOTE ]
Andy bS3 said:
What about a wee dram of Dalmore 62 yr old £25,000 a bottle /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/beerchug.gif

[/ QUOTE ]

Hehe... /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/jawdrop.gif
Thanks, I'll try the website.
 
Does it have to be Scotch?? What about a good Irish Whisky - such as Middleton...
 
[ QUOTE ]
David R said:
You absolutely cannot go wrong with an Ardbeg 17 year old. It has all of the flavours, but remains smooth and very drinkable, unlike some cheaper, newer malts....

[/ QUOTE ]
Thanks, I'll look for it.
/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/beerchug.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
JoW said:
Does it have to be Scotch?? What about a good Irish Whisky - such as Middleton...

[/ QUOTE ]
We did that last month. We are trying horizontal tastings of (the best of) regional drinks every month. In May we did Bourbon. Next month will be Cognac. In September we will be doing Port. In October we will be doing German beer.
 
Ports....
Dows or Warres are good... want something about 20 years old.
Obviously vintage... not vintage character or late bottled
 
OK OK I was just having some fun.

Here are some recommendations:

Laphoraig
Isle of Jura
Lagavulin (very unusual can be an acquired taste).
 
I thought Scotch was Tape...

Tried one called Dimple (15 Years I beleive) once, out of my father's bar and that was Ok and I don't think he'd spend more than $15 on a bottle of whisky.

Looks like you and your friends have a lot of fun!
 
Talk about diversity... I just realized how un-alike our lives have become. Here's how we stack up:
1. From Africa via E. Europe; systems analyst
2. From "Hollywood"; corp. executive
3. From New Jersey; architect
4. From Pennsylvania; U.S. Marshall
5. Then there's me... Oooooh boy!
 
What about Jonny Walker Black Label??.
 
i must agree with rouge element, highland park from the northernmost distillery is by far the most consistent and widely favored i have tried,hint of heather!!
 
I tend to go more for the islay malts like garethj recommended.
Lagavulin is my fave but the Laphroaig is also a nice drink.
These can be a bit strong tasting for some people because they have a peaty,smokey flavour to them.I think this is caused by the water on the island.
If you are after something a bit easier to drink try a Glenfiddich.You will find that the whisky from all the different regions of Scotland carry a different flavour and taste.
 
Have you had the cigar party yet?? What whiskys did you end up trying??
 
Scapa a very good whisky, sister distillery with Highland Park

Macallan

Glen Farclas

Johnny Walker Blue Label not a Malt but at the price £99 duty free is a very good one.

Take your pick there are no bad whisky's only some are better than others.



 
Building up my own collection. Personal favourites are the Cragganmore and Lagavulin 16 year.

whisky.jpg


Here's my definitive list for my collection, about half way through now, picking up most in duty free shops.

Aberfeldy
Aberlour
Ardbeg
Ardmore
Auchentoshan
Balvenie
Ben Nevis
Bladnoch
Bowmore
Bruichladdich
Bunnahabhain
Cardow
Clynelish
Cragganmore
Dailuaine
Dalmore
Dalwhinnie
Edradour
Glen Elgin
Glen Grant
Glen Moray
Glen Ord
Glen Scotia
Glen Spey
Glendronach
Glendullan
Glenfarclas
Glenfiddich
Glenfiddich Solera
Glengoyne
Glenlivet
Glenlossie
Glenmorangie
Glenturret
Highland Park
Lagavulin 16
Laphroaig
Linkwood
Longmorn
Macallan 10
Macallan 18
Macallan Cask
Mortlach
Oban
Scapa
Speyburn
Springbank
Strathisla
Talisker
Tamdhu
Teaninch
Tobermory


 
Damn Colin!

Time to start drinking some of it!

What's the bottle with the Asian writing?
 
Well guys...
The get together is tomorrow night. I'll post the results this weekend.

Thanks again for all of your input.

/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/1luvu.gif /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/1luvu.gif /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/1luvu.gif
 

Similar threads

Replies
5
Views
725
Replies
0
Views
471
Replies
8
Views
733