Finally got my car back from VRT today - given how busy they are, they still managed to fit me around their other work, so totally happy with the service.
The mechatronic unit was removed and sent to ECU Testing for a thorough test. Unfortunately the glorious Parcel Force managed to drop the package and even though it was packed well, the unit suffered some damage, which was pretty unfortunate given that it was not clear if it was the mechatronic or the input speed shaft sensor that was faulty.
View attachment 135091
One of the solenoids on the unit got pretty mangled and after further checks it was deemed as repairable with no other signs of damage to the unit. Once ECU Testing replaced the solenoid and retested the mechatronic unit, it passed all tests and was sent back to VRT to refit.
The process of removing and refitting the mechatronic unit involved draining the DSG fluid, so as part of this work VRT performed a full DSG service, replacing all DSG fluid, DSG filter with seal and the mechatronic cover gasket. The car only covered about 10k on the old DSG fluid and filter, but for the sake of 18 quid for a new filter we figured might as well do it right and service the thing again.
Obviously with the transit damage to the mechatronic I couldn't be certain that it was the component that was originally at fault and rather than risk having to remove the unit again in order to replace the input speed shaft speed sensor, I decided to replace it as a precaution. At £60+vat it's not cheap, but doing this again would cost more, plus more wasted time. Guys at VRT refitted all of the parts and did a full DSG calibration to finish things off and as soon as I knew that the car was ready, I skipped dinner and went to pick her up this evening.
So far I'm very pleased with the way it's working - no more errors on the DSG module and the shifts are barely perceptible. The old clunks during shifting between D and N are gone now too. It's early days to call it a success, but this gives me hope. What could have cost me quite a lot of money, worked out to not be as bad on the old wallet
Total cost of all this was about £400, which is much less than I anticipated. One good thing that came out of it is that I could stop freaking out about the possibility of DSG failures through learning a few things and gaining a better understanding of how they work. This is actually a good resource for anyone interested
http://www.evosoft.dk/tech.html
Other than VRT, I'd also highly recommend
ECU Testing to anyone having possible issues with ABS or DSG mechatronic units - top service and I was kept in the loop throughout the process, plus cost is actually surprisingly good given the complex nature of what they do.
Now on to another update - I've been having issues with black smoke and unburned fuel from the exhaust at WOT, which has been a bit difficult to pinpoint -
@Rick @ Unicorn Motor Dev. has sent me a few maps to try and figure this out and we managed to reduce it a bit but it is still present. VCDS logs showed me running good fuel mixture with correct lambda readings. After months of getting nowhere mainly due to the remote mapping being unavailable, it looks like Rick and Nicki from R-Tech may have found the problem... It seems that the original idea of running the RS4 fuel return valve (135bar max) fell through as the RS3 injectors do not seem to atomize the fuel fully at the lower fuel rail pressure, so the plan of running safer fuel rail pressures was flawed. With that in mind, Rick suggested getting hold of a 155bar fuel return valve to allow us to run slightly more fuel rail pressure than RS4 unit allowed and get the injectors working correctly.
I went about ordering the new fuel return valve, but knowing that running higher fuel rail pressures will put a significant strain on the HPFP cam follower and the prospect of inspecting it every 10k miles seemed a bit unpleasant, plus the risk of damaging the three HPFP bolt threads on the cam chain cover would be significantly increased as they were never designed with such frequent inspections in mind. People following this thread for a while would not be surprised by my approach to dealing with this problem, so after reading up on the upgrade, I've decided to get it done right and do away with the cam follower by upgrading it to the FSI solution, which replaces it with a roller and is meant to address the cam follower failure once and for all. Not a cheap modification, but for peace of mind it felt like the right choice.
Both, the
165bar FRV and the
cam follower kit were ordered form AKS Tuning a couple of weeks ago:
View attachment 135092 View attachment 135093
The kit is expensive, but you can get £100 back by sending your unmodified cam chain cover back, so makes it hurt a bit less
Anyway, all this goodness will be getting fitted tomorrow, so I'll post some pictures of how that goes