1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Bridgestone Potenza or Goodyear Eagle F1

Shaunos Jan 6, 2014

  1. Shaunos

    Shaunos New Member

    29
    1
    3
    Does anyone know which tyre out of the Bridgestone Potenza S001 235/40 18 and Goodyear Eagle F1 Assemetric 2 235/40 18 has got the best alloy wheel protection?
     
  2. Skandz

    Skandz Member

    42
    7
    8
    goodyear eagle f1's and the grip is spectacular.. on a quattro anyway not sure bout FWD
     
  3. Shaunos

    Shaunos New Member

    29
    1
    3


    It is the Quattro. Thanks for response!
     
  4. SinghB7

    SinghB7 Active Member

    522
    68
    28
    I have the eagle f1's on mine, has a fairly decent rim protector on them.
    Unsure about the bridgestone however.
     
  5. Gazwould

    Gazwould Well-Known Member

    4,800
    1,935
    113
    Much the same, a generous one.

    Unlike Kumho's pointless 3.5 mm offering.
     
  6. DieselJake

    DieselJake Well-Known Member

    2,425
    483
    83
    Michelin Pilot Super Sport... oh wait that's not an option :lmfao:


    Goodyear :icon_thumright: will be happy either way though
     
  7. AudiB7Jay

    AudiB7Jay Active Member Audi A4 S-line owners group Team Aruba Blue TDi saloon Manual

    448
    26
    28
    Also phenomenal on the fwd too in snow sleet rain and shine 100% recommended
     
  8. Phil-1

    Phil-1 Well-Known Member Regional Rep

    2,001
    644
    113
    I have just ordered a pair for my car. Think I got a good price, £144 fitted.
     
  9. AudiB7Jay

    AudiB7Jay Active Member Audi A4 S-line owners group Team Aruba Blue TDi saloon Manual

    448
    26
    28
    Sounds like a better price than I got last year. £250 each plus 40 fitting and balanced.
    Have a nice rim protector on them on the 235/40/18 sat on std sline 5spoke 8j alloys
     
  10. Giosabcsl

    Giosabcsl Active Member Audi A4 saloon

    853
    156
    43
    To answer to what you were asking I would say the GD year F1 AS2 has the better alloy wheel protection.

    If you were asking me which Tyre I would choose out of them I would say neither. Audi often specify not to use the GD Year AS2.

    Being a bit OCD about maintenance and care for my vehicle I like to stick to manufacture standards. And I have mentioned before in previous posts when I went and explored the GMBH factory where my Audi was built I naturally asked a lot of questions regarding the quattro system etc. The big thing they always mentioned was tyres is the biggest factor for optimal life and performance on the quattro cars. They actually gave me a list of all tyres that meet there standard and are recommended for the quattro system. Being a GD year AS2 fan for my other vehicles I noticed it was not on there. Basically it boiled down the compound being too soft, side wall is soft and the asymetric pattern causes issues - makes them prone to staggered effect or saw tooth effect . Some may have other experiences and thoughts. But for me I rather listen to these guys that built the vehicle :) All down to choice.

    If you were to ask me which tyre I would suggest for excellent grip and rim protector I would say easily:

    Michelin Pilot Sport 3 or the Dunlop Sport Maxx RT

    The Bridgestone potena s001 are noisy tyres also rated 3 noisiest tyre for the 235/40/18 range. Again preference.
     
    Last edited: Jan 7, 2014
  11. A4-Ricky

    A4-Ricky Lifeboat

    13
    3
    3
    So what did the Audi guys say to use - may help with my choice later ;)



     
  12. Giosabcsl

    Giosabcsl Active Member Audi A4 saloon

    853
    156
    43
    Well its quite a long list to be honest. It all depends on the brand you are after if you mention a few brands i can suggest which are recommend to be used with the vehicle.
     
  13. dpaz

    dpaz Active Member Team Tango

    518
    112
    43
    Dunlop Sport Maxx RT seems to have very good EU ratings. Not sure how much you can trust those new-fangled EU tyre ratings though.

    Dunlop Spot Maxx RT
    Fuel Efficiency: C
    Wet Grip: A
     
  14. DieselJake

    DieselJake Well-Known Member

    2,425
    483
    83
    All I know is they make some damn fine tennis racquets haha, to be honest it puts me off a brand when they think they're jack of all trades; e.g. Phillips making coffee machines, razors, irons, light bulbs, televisions, juicers, tooth brushes, head units, etc. I'm sure both brands are good in all aspects but prefer picking one that focuses on one specific area.
     
  15. Gazwould

    Gazwould Well-Known Member

    4,800
    1,935
    113
    Goodyear own Dunlop.
     
  16. JAMason

    JAMason New Member

    11
    1
    1
    Iv used the continental eco contacts on my previous cars and been happy with them, and an S4 owning friend of mine uses the continental sport contact 2 on his cars. Not sure about the rim protection, i don't think it was very big so they might not be much use.

    My Girlfriends dad has the Bridgstones Potenza fitted to his Subaru WRX ProDrive and loves them. They have a fairly big rim protection but then the down side is, they aren't all that much use in the snow. They are more a fair weather tyre!

    Jack
     
  17. DieselJake

    DieselJake Well-Known Member

    2,425
    483
    83
    VW owns Bugatti :p



    Edit: Not sure if the reasoning behind that was made clear but there's a difference in one company trying to be jack of all trades and one splitting apart with different names, strategies and aims.
     
    Last edited: Jan 9, 2014
  18. Graemetee

    Graemetee Member

    57
    5
    8
    I think I'd trust the EU tyre ratings about as much as I trust the EU fuel consumption figures!!
     
  19. gatuno12

    gatuno12 New Member

    17
    12
    3
    I have used the assymetrics 2 and the potenzas s04, never used the s001 so i can tell you this:

    Both are amazing tyres, it is clear that the assymetrics have better traction and stopping power, in handling i had the feeling that the assymetrics were a bit softer although they where progresive and very grippy. The s04,s were grippy but not as proggresive . Both turned to be very comfortable in every day use although the assymetrics were quieter.

    The rim prottection of the assymetrics is good , i guess it has a 6 mm protection band , same
    As the bridgestones.


    Both
     
  20. Ant600

    Ant600 Member

    64
    5
    8
    I'm a big fan of potenzas they last a long time too . Also continental conti sports are good but a bit pricey . Just don't go for nankang ditch finders :)
     
  21. mancdan

    mancdan Active Member

    491
    50
    28
  22. jdp1962

    jdp1962 Grumpy Old Moderator Staff Member Moderator TFSI Owners Group Team V6 Gold Supporter Team Tornado Audi S4 quattro Black Edition s tronic

    8,203
    2,690
    113
    I've been looking for a while at what to fit next, as my current tyres are coming to the end of their useful life. I'm closing in on the Dunlop Sport Maxx RT.
     

Share This Page