1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

S3 Saloon arriving next week - security?

sagaris99 May 29, 2019

  1. sagaris99

    sagaris99 New Member

    17
    12
    3
    Hi all, eagerly awaiting the arrival of a 67 plate S3 Saloon in Nano grey next week

    Have read and heard about the unfortunate attraction of these cars to thieves, and understand that advanced key (keyless go) is a major chink in the security of cars like this.

    My car will not have advanced key, instead a convention remote unlocking key and physical barrel in the steering wheel, with steering lock.

    Being pushed my dad to buy a DiskLok, slightly put off by the price but accept that it’s better than losing the car. My question is, given the steering lock, automatic gearbox in park and electronic parking brake, which can only be disabled with the ignition on, what is disklok actually offering me? The car can’t be moved (afaik) without the ignition, and I would expect the way the car is designed that should be impossible?? Wondering if my money would be better spent on GAP insurance or something like automatics trackers etc
     
  2. Avatar

    Google AdSense Advertisement


  3. Adam14

    Adam14 Well-Known Member Team Glacier Team V6 Audi S5 Coupe

    1,734
    1,563
    113
    There's nothing stopping (if determined) them just dragging your car off the driveway. Parking brake or not. Disklock of course won't stop it either but once they've got it they can then try and remove the disklock etc. However it would deter someone if they were just attempting to break in to the car and steal it

    Imo you should have gap insurance regardless. Very cheap in comparison to what it offers you.

    My personal opinion (after having one fitted to my S3) is that if my car was stolen, I don't really want it back. Also after fitting a tracker my insurance company wanted more money, despite the fact that it saves them money.

    Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
     
  4. B5NUT

    B5NUT Well-Known Member TFSI Owners Group VCDS Map User Audi A6 Audi A3 Audi Avant Owner Group quattro S tronic S-line owners group

    4,867
    1,136
    113
    If they want the car they will try and break into the house and steal the keys, these scum bags are getting more and more audacious these days. best option is to keep the car away from public view if possible.
     
  5. loftylad

    loftylad Gone but not forgotten.

    317
    365
    63
    My personal opinion is forget any type of physical deterrent. If the scrotes want it, do you really want them waking you or your partner up at 2 in the morning demanding the keys/codes/whatever else.

    Spend your money on insurance from a reputable company and get GAP insurance.

    Keep the car out of sight as best you can (garaged if possible) and just be aware when nearing home of being followed.

    I know loads on here say Ghost/trackers and the like, but if mine got stolen no way would I want it back.

    Thefts of these types of cars are rife as there’s pretty much no chance of being caught and even less chance of prosecution even if they are. Risk vs reward. Very easy money for the low lives. Rob a post office tooled up and you’ll do jail time. Break into a house and steal someone’s 40k car, and you’ll be lucky if you get community service.

    This is all worst case scenario, but it does happen and it forewarned is forearmed.
     
    Ron240, sagaris99 and B5NUT like this.
  6. Ron240

    Ron240 Breaking the stereotype Team Ara Blue Gold Supporter S3 Saloon Black Edition

    937
    1,129
    93
    As others have said....I wouldn't want my car back either if it was stolen, so a tracker would be completely out of the question for me.
    I was watching Police Interceptors the other night and they were looking for a stolen Golf fitted with a tracker. They found it and a high speed chase began......over speed bumps, kerbs, even off road up a grassy bank! The car was being driven so fast and erratically that the police lost it.....only to later find it abandoned thanks to the tracker.
    The final shot was of it being winched onto a tow truck with the commentator saying it would be returned to its owner.
    Well if that was my car there's no way I would be wanting it back!!
     
    OCDaveS3, Pinky1959 and Adam14 like this.
  7. Baldyone

    Baldyone Well-Known Member Sportback Team Navarra Audi S3 quattro S tronic

    265
    279
    63
    New S3 delivered this morning at 9am, autowatch ghost installed this afternoon at 16:00
    It’s a really clever bit of kit and a no brainier at 1% of the cars cost. Alarm on the home plus security cameras front and rear to keep the good lady happy and anti-snap locks. Visible steering lock in place (pain in the bum that it is) and I will be taking my keys to bed with me as I always do. I appreciate this is a bit contentious and feel for anyone that’s suffered a home break in for a car but no way will I allow taking my car be easy. Yes it can be replaced but no scum bag has any right to enter my home or take my property and I will absolutely put up a fight for it. Not getting into specifics, rights, wrongs, and totally respect the idea of leaving it so if targeted, it’s just the car that goes and nothing else. I remember the poor guy a year or so ago that was killed for a Saloon and it just got dumped after they ran him over. Terrible waste of life, however disturb my much needed sleep in the night trying to take what I work really hard for, I’ll be jumping out of bed like my gents sausage has been bitten by a bittey thing and doing my best to cause any would be invader a really really bad headache!
     
  8. oli356

    oli356 Well-Known Member Sportback Team Sepang Audi S3 Black Edition S tronic

    1,710
    1,466
    113
    And if the invader(s) actually gives you a really bad headache lol?

    I'd rather them just take the keys and go. Rather deal with insurance than a possible stab wound or something.
     
  9. Baldyone

    Baldyone Well-Known Member Sportback Team Navarra Audi S3 quattro S tronic

    265
    279
    63
    Like I said, contentious;) however by that time my home alarm will be howling. There will have been noisy damage to get in. My Mrs will be screaming (probably at me and trust me, that’ll have the toughest or scum bags heading for the door) and if I am in some way impeded, Mr Butt Head (or Mrs, let’s not be sexist here) wont be getting my Ghost code will he / she. Whatever any of us say and either side of the debate, we’ll never really know until we find ourselves in that situation and I would never judge any one who’s been there. All I know for sure is I intend to do everything I can to make any potential theft of my car as challenging as eating fruit pastilles and not chewing, and I’ll be a little annoyed should they try
     
  10. Adam14

    Adam14 Well-Known Member Team Glacier Team V6 Audi S5 Coupe

    1,734
    1,563
    113
    This can go down multiple routes. Can see both sides. Yes they have no right to my car, but a car can be replaced, a life cannot. Yes I'd be ****** if someone nicked my car but I'd rather that than someone hurt.

    Yea I've got security cameras, couple of alsatians and home alarm which are good deterrents but half the time these people are desperate. They won't care!

    Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
     
    loftylad likes this.
  11. jassyo06

    jassyo06 Voodoo Man ! S3 Saloon Audi S3 Black Edition Porsche Voodoo Blue

    17,822
    36,493
    113
    A S3 in Nano Grey there's not a chance it'll get stolen..............lol
     
  12. Avatar

    Google AdSense Advertisement


  13. Kieran Johnson

    Kieran Johnson Active Member

    231
    88
    28
    My current car has keyless entry so I park my van across the drive to block it in and also make sure Both keys are disabled in the evenings. I tried wheel clamps and steering locks but got bored of doing that all the time. My next car will have ghost (I think I was offered £350 installed) and GAP.
    I also have a RING door bell to check on it whenever I want.
     
    sagaris99 and Baldyone like this.
  14. Adam14

    Adam14 Well-Known Member Team Glacier Team V6 Audi S5 Coupe

    1,734
    1,563
    113
    Just stick your keys in a biscuit tin. Prevents the relay hack. Or get those £5 pouches. But the van idea is golden

    Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
     
  15. Baldyone

    Baldyone Well-Known Member Sportback Team Navarra Audi S3 quattro S tronic

    265
    279
    63
    classy reply :tonguewink:
     
    Last edited: May 29, 2019
  16. jassyo06

    jassyo06 Voodoo Man ! S3 Saloon Audi S3 Black Edition Porsche Voodoo Blue

    17,822
    36,493
    113
    Always speak the truth...
     
    Baldyone likes this.
  17. Baldyone

    Baldyone Well-Known Member Sportback Team Navarra Audi S3 quattro S tronic

    265
    279
    63
    Yep, van blocking mine too and a Ring door bell for the view. Honestly thought they where some kinda gimmick when they first came out, kinda like an iPhone watch “how’s that ever gonna work?” (Can’t live without mine now), however I’m one for turning and I’m well impressed with my Ring
     
    Kieran Johnson likes this.
  18. Adam14

    Adam14 Well-Known Member Team Glacier Team V6 Audi S5 Coupe

    1,734
    1,563
    113
    Ring doorbell is fantastic. Great for when you have parcels and you're not home as well

    Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
     
    Baldyone likes this.
  19. Mr Freeze

    Mr Freeze Active Member

    180
    133
    43
    Going back a few years here a guy on my street had a brand new civic type R when they first hit uk roads
    two weeks into owning it he was woken one night by a loud bang upon opening his bedroom window there were four masked
    men asking for his car keys and threatening to enter his house if he didn't hand them over . The car was found the next day through
    the tracker by the police with a hand gun in the glove box and red dye all over the seats . Three week later he had a skoda on the drive
    and said he wouldn't buy a performance car again . If it happened to me i'd just hand the keys over as you just never know how far they
    are willing to go .
     
    Adam14 likes this.
  20. JohnM100

    JohnM100 Well-Known Member Gold Supporter VCDS Map User Team Navarra Audi S3 Black Edition

    1,198
    563
    113
    Shame the app has become so bloated that by the time it opens on your phone, the person has given up waiting - and its a new fast phone so thats not the cause.


    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro
     
  21. Adam14

    Adam14 Well-Known Member Team Glacier Team V6 Audi S5 Coupe

    1,734
    1,563
    113
    Can't say I have the same issue. Loads quickly for me (on Samsung S9+). Got the flood camera and doorbell, however don't have that "live view" screen turned on. Maybe why.

    Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
     
  22. Baldyone

    Baldyone Well-Known Member Sportback Team Navarra Audi S3 quattro S tronic

    265
    279
    63
    Haven’t had to use it in that way yet. My little bro is staying with us at the mo and highlight so far is watching the numpty try to return home quietly in the early hours of the morning totally p’sd! Hilarious watch back. If he wakes the dogs, the wife will bite! I’ve a van not for commercial reasons but because the good lady of the house has all Amazon orders directed to my work and no car is big enough for me to get them home each day. Now it adds to car security too :)
    Steering lock on that just to make it even more off a ball ache in the mornings!.....and more troubling for any swag bag man too
     
    Kieran Johnson likes this.
  23. Kieran Johnson

    Kieran Johnson Active Member

    231
    88
    28
    Have you checked the signal strength for the device? If it’s poor you can buy a booster which may improve this. I don’t have any issues with my iPhone 8 and 8+.
    Also, I don’t close the ring app
     
    Last edited: May 30, 2019
  24. OCDaveS3

    OCDaveS3 Well-Known Member Silver Supporter Team Navarra Audi S3

    225
    381
    63
    You need a Navarra Blue version - its like some kind of stealth car at night - can't see the flippin thing ! (mind you, no street lights where I am !) . On the "van" theme, I might start parking SWMBO's beloved Toyota in front ! S3 keys go in a tin every night.....

    ...I suppose the other thing is to wash it with Fairy, fit a towbar, roofbox and some mudflaps.............:tearsofjoy:
     
    Baldyone and jassyo06 like this.
  25. wab172uk

    wab172uk Well-Known Member

    1,069
    1,046
    113
    GAP insurance? Yes. A must.
    Tracker? No. Would you really want it back?
    Disklok? Yes, as it will deter the opportunist .

    If you have a garage, use it. If they can't see it, they can't steal it.

    End of the day, you can only do so much. Baring connecting it up to the mains like some guy did back in the day with his Sapphire Cosworth, then if they want it, they'll take it. And unfortunately if that means stabbing you, then they will.

    Always keep your car key downstairs. If they do break in for the keys, let them see them, take them, and get out. Hiding them or taking them upstairs only invites them upstairs where you and your family are sleeping.

    Now the insurance companies have started kicking up a fuss regarding `Keyless Go` I suspect manufacturers will provably stop using them. If insurance companies stop insuring, or vastly up'ing the cost of insuring a car with Keyless, then no one is going to buy a car the keyless. Manufacturers will soon get the message. Unfortunately people with car that already have keyless, they could get stung in the wallet.
     
  26. DAN@ADRIAN FLUX

    DAN@ADRIAN FLUX Site Sponsor Site Sponsor

    352
    80
    28
  27. davc

    davc Well-Known Member Team Glacier S3 Saloon Audi S3 saloon quattro S tronic

    927
    929
    93
    You mean invaders, there is usually a few of them.

    I suggest you buy an axe then and keep it by your bed.
     
  28. Adam14

    Adam14 Well-Known Member Team Glacier Team V6 Audi S5 Coupe

    1,734
    1,563
    113
    Apart from the fact you could then be sued or face criminal charges as that is not "reasonable force".

    Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
     
  29. davc

    davc Well-Known Member Team Glacier S3 Saloon Audi S3 saloon quattro S tronic

    927
    929
    93
    I hear ya.

    However, I do wonder what constitutes reasonable force when confronted by several armed intruders in the middle of the night.
     
  30. loftylad

    loftylad Gone but not forgotten.

    317
    365
    63
    It’s funny how some people think they’re “terry-ten-men” when it comes to confronting determined thieves.

    Professional car thieves are career hardened scum and real pieces of work. Stealing motors is their “job”. Even if you’re Bruce Lee, what do you think you’re going to do at 2am, bleary eyed when you’ve got 4 balaclava’d up hard men tooled up with absolutely nothing to lose demanding keys or the code to your ghost immobiliser?

    As for the hassle of putting on and taking off stuff like disc locks? What’s the point? Opportunists can’t take these kind of motors without the keys. All you’re doing is making it a ball ache for yourselves every time you get in or out of your car.

    It’s a car. It can be replaced. Insure it, GAP it and garage or hide it away.

    Unfortunately, it’s only going to get worse, as there’s absolutely no deterrent or punishment for this type of crime. The detection and prosecution numbers are pitiful. Easy money for these cretinous low life oxygen robbers who make hard working peoples lives miserable.

    I’d stop this overnight if I were in power. It’s real simple. Chop their hands off. See how many cars go missing after “aspiring footballer and loveable rouge” Johnny Scrote is pictured on the 6 o clock news with two stumps.:icon thumright:
     
    wab172uk, Mr Freeze and Adam14 like this.
  31. Moranatang

    Moranatang New Member Team Daytona Audi S3 Black Edition It's my birthday

    19
    21
    3
    I had an attempted theft of mine back in March we weren’t in at the time. The house alarm and big metal sliding electric gate didn’t deter them. As the cars not keyless they were looking for the keys which they didn’t find. They didn’t realise the house alarmed was monitored and the police were around in minutes we think they ran off as they arrived. These thief’s are not after a confrontation as it’s goes from burglary to aggravated burglary and sentence time is increased. They want to get your keys silently or keyless so the cars gone before you know. If you ever confronted best going for one of them and scratch them or rip the hair out and try get dna that way if I get one chance of getting them all. I wouldn’t say there hard men at all easier thinking your hard tooled up rather than looking for a fist fight. Most of these think there professionals most case they aren’t just after a easy picking and the equipment they use is easily available.
     
    Martinbanshee and oli356 like this.
  32. oli356

    oli356 Well-Known Member Sportback Team Sepang Audi S3 Black Edition S tronic

    1,710
    1,466
    113
    I would agree with this and it's why I think the whole idea of installing the ghost system and then worrying about the thieves forcing the code out of you is a bit.. Unlikely.

    Not saying it would never happen, but over an average car like an s3 or rs3.....? Do they really want to increase the chance of being caught or harm to themselves..

    In the Audi range these cars are still somewhat low end. My neighbour has a BMW X3 and the other side has a Land Rover Discovery. Both cars are the same price if not more than these Audis. My point being, they are hardly the most expensive cars on the road. Of course if they are being stolen as a get away car then those 2 examples maybe aren't the best car choice but in terms of value atleast....

    So yeah, I think forcing a code out of you is an unlikely scenario. More like the car doesn't start, let's get the heck out of here.
    Maybe if it's a rare or a super car or you live in the middle of no where so not any neighbors around that could spot you etc... Then maybe.
     
  33. Avatar

    Google AdSense Advertisement


  34. A1DEYB

    A1DEYB Well-Known Member

    1,950
    201
    63
    And that's whats wrong with today.. To me taking an axe to someone who's broken into your house isn't enough reasonable force.

    A criminal entering someones deserves everything they get and the law should say so.

    Country is sorry should i say, has gone to the dogs.
     
    davc, Adam14 and loftylad like this.
  35. A1DEYB

    A1DEYB Well-Known Member

    1,950
    201
    63
     
    Last edited: May 31, 2019
    loftylad likes this.
  36. zaka7

    zaka7 Well-Known Member Sportback Team Nardo Audi RS3 S tronic

    495
    371
    63
    Reasonable force enables the use of a weapon in the heat of the moment if you feel your life is in danger, tooled up intruders would constitute this. When the use of a weapon is not reasonable force is when you 'lay a trap' or 'continue using it' when you've already debilitated them. Basically if you have an axe, hammer, crowbar or anything, you've got one shot. Make it a good one and nail the scumbag(s).

    https://www.cps.gov.uk/sites/default/files/documents/publications/householders-2013.pdf

    I'm very much on the make it as hard as possible approach, 99.9% want your keys without alerting you, They want to be in an out and long gone before you even realise the car is gone. You can make that impossible with alarms, steering locks, motion detection, cctv and alike. The 0.1% of nutters can still be deterred and delayed with clever tactics as we all know, but at the end of the day cars are replaceable and we all have insurance. I'm not looking to give my car up without a fight, I've worked hard for it, why should I have to just let it go without a fuss and then live with heightened insurance policies for the rest of my life!
    Equally not looking to lose my life over a bit of metal and everyone has limits.
     
  37. loftylad

    loftylad Gone but not forgotten.

    317
    365
    63
    The thing is, 15 years ago there was a real chance of being caught and securing a conviction. Today, there is pretty much no chance of getting caught and even if they are caught, sentences are laughable.

    Scum know this and are taking full advantage of it. It’s definitely getting worse and more frequent.
     
  38. A1DEYB

    A1DEYB Well-Known Member

    1,950
    201
    63
    Trouble is that all depends on interpretation as to why an axe is sticking out of the back of someones head in first place, if the law read something along the lines of and made it clear that ANY FORCE is deemed as reasonable then maybe these feckers would think twice.

    I'm convinced that we will see more criminals ending up getting fecked up having entered someones home to burgle it because people have had enough of absolute shambolic laws, justice system and the fannying about protecting the criminals from proper justice.

    I value my life, my Mrs and my sons so i wouldn't confront someone unless i really thought i had the upper hand and could absolutely annihilate one of them, trouble is they no where you live, you don't know where they live.
     
  39. zaka7

    zaka7 Well-Known Member Sportback Team Nardo Audi RS3 S tronic

    495
    371
    63
    It does state that "this includes the use of a weapon" If you fear for your life and in the heat of the moment decide to whack an axe across someones head so be it. More and more we are seeing people get done over after breaking into someones home and getting let off. This includes stabbing, shooting and a claw hammer.
    That said if you hit them once and the threat is gone, but then you continue you're then in for a whole world of pain, that is NOT reasonable force. Neither would sneaking up on them be, However, If they came storming into your room and you grabbed an axe and hit them once, that is reasonable force, it's the heat of the moment, you don't have time to think and your life is clearly in danger.

    They could make the law clearer I agree, personally if someone breaks into my house and believes they have the right to take whats mine, I believe I should have the right to take what's theirs and cut their hands off! That'd soon stop them and certainly stop people going to jail for 10 days and then doing it again the night of their release.
     
  40. A1DEYB

    A1DEYB Well-Known Member

    1,950
    201
    63
    Absolutely spot on.
     
    zaka7 likes this.
  41. TonkS3

    TonkS3 Member Team Ara Blue S3 Saloon Audi S3

    51
    33
    18
    I'd like to think that I'd back myself against a couple of people in my house trying to get my motor, but in reality they are going to be spraying a fire extinguisher in your face before you can get anywhere near them. I'm more worried about them letting the house cat out than taking the car. Get gap insurance and try not to worry about it. Thinking that its going to get stolen every night when you go to sleep soon takes the edge off having a nice car :(.
     
  42. zaka7

    zaka7 Well-Known Member Sportback Team Nardo Audi RS3 S tronic

    495
    371
    63
    If you have a house alarm and hidden motion detection triggers, you'll be awake and know where they are before they can surprise you with something like that. It's not just a deterrent to most, but more of a I know i'll be awake and aware what is happening, it takes even the most bullish of crooks element of surprise away.
     
  43. Nick Moorhouse

    Nick Moorhouse Lemski

    58
    51
    18
    General consensus is if they want it they'll take it. By any means possible....All you can do is try and make it as difficult for them as possible.

    Regarding GAP insurance.....I'm not a fan. I paid for my car outright so that makes a difference. Finance however is a different story. It does depend on your circumstances...Have a good read of the below link.

    https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/car-insurance/gap-insurance/
     

Share This Page