Coked up valves have associated problems like rough idle, smoking, poor fuel consumption. whatever remady you use will either fix the problem or not regardless of what the parts look like after.
I had an engine management light come on at 50k miles. (rich at idle) and it was smoking on hard acceleration,j It went in to a main dealer 3 times and an indi 4 times over the next 2 years. No one could put the light out for more than 120 miles. It had countless parts from solenoid valves to charcoal filters /canisters, plugs/MAF and so on and eventually i was talking to guy with and independent Mini dealership and he said bring it in to me and i will hydro clean it, apparently Minis are really bad for this .
Took it in, the light went out, been out for 20k miles now, rolling road showed 381bhp. tick over is such that you might think it had stalled its so smooth and it stopped smoking.
Now people can say its a waste of time and money but it worked for me.