1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. Dismiss Notice

Autocar Audi S3 Saloon review

foofoo Oct 21, 2020

  1. foofoo

    foofoo Registered User

    51
    84
    18
    Marinos Demetriou likes this.
  2. Avatar

    snack-media
    Advertisement


  3. dbm

    dbm Registered User

    721
    250
    63
    Sounds promising, just wish the interior ergonomics were better. I lament the obsession with touch screens for cars...
     
    RGBARGEE and T-1000 like this.
  4. T-1000

    T-1000 Registered User

    958
    832
    93
    Ghastly dashboard


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
    Mr Freeze and TYb like this.
  5. jassyo06

    jassyo06 T-Cut King !

    19,302
    39,279
    113
    I have no problems with dashboard once sat in the car...its actually very nice....its the terrible plastic door arms and rear interior door cards that look as if they've been taken from a Suzuki

    Sent from my SM-A715F using Tapatalk
     
    Sparks43 and T-1000 like this.
  6. T-1000

    T-1000 Registered User

    958
    832
    93
    Sorry but I can’t get over the myriad of design elements that conflict, because of those stuck on Air vents the VC looks lost in a sea of dash plastic


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
    tickedon, Mr Freeze and TYb like this.
  7. voorhees

    voorhees Moderator Staff Member Moderator

    16,708
    2,563
    113
    It looks like its been T-boned by a hummer at the side :/ Interior isn't as bad as the new Golf
     
    X3man likes this.
  8. T-1000

    T-1000 Registered User

    958
    832
    93
    This says it all about the dash.
    [​IMG]


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
    pburv, TYb and X3man like this.
  9. terminator x

    terminator x Registered User

    4,702
    5,367
    113
    If Audi quality is now no better than VW then surely people just won't pay the premium ...

    TX.

    Sent from my BBB100-2 using Tapatalk
     
    T-1000 likes this.
  10. T-1000

    T-1000 Registered User

    958
    832
    93
    8V FL dash / interior is now one they couldn’t actually improve on


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
    pburv and Mr Freeze like this.
  11. Mr Freeze

    Mr Freeze Registered User

    610
    590
    93
    Totally agree . The new dash is terrible and not a patch on the 8v dash .
     
    T-1000 likes this.
  12. Avatar

    snack-media
    Advertisement


  13. Sparks43

    Sparks43 3rd Gear

    581
    235
    43
    You say that now, but until you actually have one for a period of time it's difficult to make that assumption surely - I love my 8V dash, but our works pool car is a Seat Leon last of the old model and having been driving it for the last 6 months, you do get used to the touchscreen etc

    You can't stay with the old dash forever, whilst everybody else goes touchscreen otherwise people will just say Audi aren't moving with the times and they are having to look towards the younger generation who only know touchscreens etc
     
    X3man and tb123 like this.
  14. tb123

    tb123 Member

    49
    38
    18
    And this is the situation I find myself in, looking at the new RS3, probably won’t be available here in Australia until 2022, so by then, the current dash will be going on 10 years old, will be 15 if I keep the car 5 years. I can’t justify spending what is a significant amount if money (to me at least) on something that whilst feels more premium, is so far out of date already.

    I have a touchscreen in my current Mk7.5 Golf, it works well and I almost never need to touch it while driving, there are enough buttons on the wheel and dash that common functions are easily executed “old skool”.
     
    X3man likes this.
  15. Dubjam

    Dubjam Moderator Staff Member Moderator VCDS Map User

    1,164
    423
    83
    You can tell there is a fair amount of industry backhanders going on with the new A3 reviews..they seem to omit things like the plastic and hideous dashboard, and overall very poor looks etc.
     
  16. Mr Freeze

    Mr Freeze Registered User

    610
    590
    93
    I get what you are saying but my issue isn't the touch screen its the over all look of the new dash . Like you say after a period of time you would get used to it .
     
  17. AdamInKent

    AdamInKent New Member

    29
    18
    3
    I have read and watched a lot of reviews over the past few months. Many, if not the majority, discuss the drop in the quality of some of the interior materials. They all consider the new looks.

    Whether or not you like the new dash is very much down to personal preference. As someone who has never owned an A3 before, I like it: I prefer it to the outgoing design. It’s worth mentioning that the interior looks nicer IRL than it does in photos and video and the touch points have a quality feel.
     
    Last edited: Oct 26, 2020
  18. Dubjam

    Dubjam Moderator Staff Member Moderator VCDS Map User

    1,164
    423
    83
    Would you be able to link some of these discussions?

    I think personal preference is one thing, not everyone has taste that's for sure :friendly wink:. But from a design perspective, it's a bit of a hash.

    Having spent some time in one, I can definitely say for me it looks about the same as in photos, which actually made me quite sad as I was hoping that it would be 'more' than what it looked like. The side plastics and rear door cards are a disgrace and abusive to the customer at this price point.

    Aside from the natural evolution of tech, the seats I think are the only real improvement over the 8V.

    Interesting though, as these designs are created with a marketing strategy, so if you are new to fold, maybe they are concentrating on a new customer base, rather than retaining old ones.
     
  19. Walternate

    Walternate Guest

    0
    0
    0
    My thoughts exactly
     
  20. AdamInKent

    AdamInKent New Member

    29
    18
    3
    You could well be right about the design decision. But then, any significant change in design risks being considered a step back by those who like the existing one? Personally, I’m not a fan of the big round air vents and pop-up screen in the 8V: but I understand that’s going to be a minority view amongst a group of people who own a car with big round vents and a pop up screen ;-D

    As for reviews that consider the material quality, here are two for starters:

    https://www.topgear.com/car-reviews/audi/a3-sportback
    Angular interior design and mish-mashed trim materials don’t look or feel as expensive as an Audi ought to

    https://www.carwow.co.uk/audi/a3/interior#nav
    “...if you look hard enough though, some of the materials feel a bit cheap.”
     
    Last edited: Oct 26, 2020
  21. Dubjam

    Dubjam Moderator Staff Member Moderator VCDS Map User

    1,164
    423
    83
    It's a step back, because it is a step back based on poor design and poor materials.

    You mentioned you havent owned an 8V (have you owned any other incarnations of the car?). The 8V was a great evolution from the 8P which also had a brilliant interior, that even nearly 20 years on is still a very nice place to be, almost timeless. The 8v extended this with more premium materials, and as such won massive praise as being one of the best interiors in a car. It was pretty much an unanimous feeling within the entire industry, and not so much just personal opinions.

    The 8Y has already seen its negative elements expressed and created a marmite effect. With the cost cutting taking place to pay for Dieselgate, this has really shown in the build of the interior - which maybe acceptable to you as a new customer, but those that have experienced better, many realise it is a huge step down for a step up in price. It's not so much about personal preference, its about experience and expecting evolution not devolution. Granted, the new tech and the dopamine enhancing technicolour of the new displays and 'modern' factor can create a diversion effect from what is essentially bad design, thus many customers will buy into it and feel its an improvement, which is a clever trick of marketing and design psychology working together.

    This is a great example of my point regarding backhanding media bias, it dosent take anyone to look 'hard' enough to see the poor quality materials, a blind person would find them just as quickly, even more so if you have experience of how premium the A3 had evolved to. The ambiguity in that statement 'brushes' over the facts to avoid angering the brand. Having worked in marketing for a long long time, I can assure you, these things are taken into consideration quite heavily.

    For me, the 8Y is being marketed to the Bluetooth speaker generation, forget quality, just make it happen, and make it happen loud.
     
    Last edited: Oct 27, 2020
  22. Euans2

    Euans2 Registered User

    275
    56
    28
    I own both an 8v and an 8y, imo, the interior on the 8v is starting to look a bit dated, however, there is no escaping that some or the plastics are nicer in the 8v but that doesn’t make the 8y a horrible place to be, I find it quite pleasing, most of the lower quality plastics are in areas that don’t bother me, I think the vents are in a better place and don’t look as bad as they do in the pictures and the MMI is easy enough to use once you’re used to it, even voice activation picks up my Scottish twang first time lol.

    I get that people aren’t happy about some or the choices made when designing the 8y, we inherently don’t like change, I was the same until I took one out for a test drive
     
    AdamInKent likes this.
  23. T-1000

    T-1000 Registered User

    958
    832
    93
    Even those plonked on the binnacle air vents
    Makes that area quite dark I remember thinking when I sat in one.
    VC looks lost in the middle of all that dash plastic.
    I was actually wondering what the stitching effect on the dash was trying to say ....sorry for the drivers side maybe ?


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
    Snake Pliskin and Dubjam like this.
  24. jassyo06

    jassyo06 T-Cut King !

    19,302
    39,279
    113
    Stitching on the dash is the same as the ones on Frankenstein masks you get at Halloween

    Sent from my SM-A715F using Tapatalk
     
    Snake Pliskin and T-1000 like this.
  25. T-1000

    T-1000 Registered User

    958
    832
    93
    FrankenA3


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
    jassyo06 and Snake Pliskin like this.
  26. Dubjam

    Dubjam Moderator Staff Member Moderator VCDS Map User

    1,164
    423
    83
    ...in Poundstretcher..
     
    jassyo06 and Snake Pliskin like this.
  27. Euans2

    Euans2 Registered User

    275
    56
    28
    Thankfully, not all the models have the stitching on the dash
     
  28. Snake Pliskin

    Snake Pliskin Well-Known Member Supporter

    4,623
    6,916
    113

    even compared to a lambo, the vents are ludicrously high lol

    plus I think the fact they do not align with the passenger side vents accentuates their unusually high position further ....

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]
     
    Jcbmally and T-1000 like this.
  29. T-1000

    T-1000 Registered User

    958
    832
    93
    Even the Seat Leon gets them symmetrical kind of.

    [​IMG]


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
    Jcbmally, Snake Pliskin and pburv like this.
  30. pburv

    pburv Registered User

    6,455
    12,730
    113
    Been looking at another Leon for my wife...Need to get rid of her Q3 . I have yet to sit in the new Leon hopefully once the lockdown has been and gone we will go to our local Seat dealership.
     
    Jcbmally, Snake Pliskin and jassyo06 like this.
  31. jassyo06

    jassyo06 T-Cut King !

    19,302
    39,279
    113
    Yer kidding me right the welsh gov have shut business's down....ie dealerships?

    Sent from my SM-A715F using Tapatalk
     
  32. pburv

    pburv Registered User

    6,455
    12,730
    113
    Lol Yeah....Even just thinking of buying anything other than food or medicine is considered a capital offence. :scared2:
    Until the 9th of November anyway:blink:
     
    Jcbmally, Snake Pliskin and T-1000 like this.
  33. Avatar

    snack-media
    Advertisement


  34. jassyo06

    jassyo06 T-Cut King !

    19,302
    39,279
    113
    Disgraceful mate non compliance by business's has got to happen....soon

    Sent from my SM-A715F using Tapatalk
     
    Jcbmally, pburv and Snake Pliskin like this.
  35. pburv

    pburv Registered User

    6,455
    12,730
    113
    Not good is it.:sadlike: There's more to come I think??
     
    Jcbmally, Snake Pliskin and jassyo06 like this.
  36. Dubjam

    Dubjam Moderator Staff Member Moderator VCDS Map User

    1,164
    423
    83
    It should have been done properly the first time, then this wouldn't of needed to happen.
     
  37. Mr Freeze

    Mr Freeze Registered User

    610
    590
    93
    I agree it should of been handled better the first time round . I 'am currently self isolating after testing positive for covid last Tuesday
    it as totally floored me I wouldn't wish it on anybody .
     
  38. Dubjam

    Dubjam Moderator Staff Member Moderator VCDS Map User

    1,164
    423
    83
    I’m sorry to hear that dude :(
     
    Jcbmally and Mr Freeze like this.
  39. pburv

    pburv Registered User

    6,455
    12,730
    113
    Hope you have a quick recovery:thumbs up:
     
    Jcbmally and Mr Freeze like this.
  40. Snake Pliskin

    Snake Pliskin Well-Known Member Supporter

    4,623
    6,916
    113
    Yeah sorry to hear that mate ... sending you lots of get well soon wishes :icon thumright:
     
    Mr Freeze likes this.
  41. X3man

    X3man Well known member

    6,600
    8,568
    113
    All the best for a speedy recovery mate
     
    Mr Freeze likes this.
  42. Mr Freeze

    Mr Freeze Registered User

    610
    590
    93
    Thank you for all for the kind comments :icon thumright:
     
  43. jassyo06

    jassyo06 T-Cut King !

    19,302
    39,279
    113
    Covid-19 discussion is a volatile Topic as most people have now a lot of built up frustrations/anger on the subject....."Governments"....and l appreciate you've not been feeling great at all but no doubt you'll back to your own highly opinionated self soon....lol
     
    pburv likes this.

Share This Page

Do Not Sell My Personal Information