Surprised by that to be honest.
That being said, I think that there could be a good chunk of time saved by the RS3 if it was on the Michellin PS4S's like the A45. Those Pirelli's aren't exactly renowned for being good in the wet/cool.
I've had both and traded an A45 to get the 8Y.
The result doesn't surprise me tbh .... ON THE TRACK !
The A45 I found needed to thrashed and red lined to make it exciting, which on public roads you struggle to do.
If you can bang it through the gears on track I can imagine it would be fantastic and then the engine / exhaust does come to life too.
It also felt a very nimble car in terms of handling.
Sadly I found that did not translate to a good or exciting car as a daily.
The 4 pot engine sounded like a dyson, there was literally NO SOUND whatsoever driving around town a to b and nothing even on start up.
The seats were again fantastic for supportive fast driving but around town not so much - so the comment on the RS3's buckets being uncomfortable could well be a factor vs the standard regular seats.
I can understand the attraction of getting the buckets to lift the interior but I'd definitely want to sit in them before ordering.
Regardless of what Plato says, on reflection I still personally preferred the RS3.