This time, you get 0/10 for originality- just echoing my avatar.
This is not a new debate. Regulars have seen this time and again since 2013/14.
It comes around every time new guys like yourself buy an S3 and comes on here and thinks it's a new debate - or thinks they bring something new to it.
I've been reading this forum for a few years now, from the time I bought my MKVI R - I start shopping the day I buy a new car to see what is next on line. I start posting once I have the car. Have already started researching the next car (Tesla).
I don't see avatars on Tapatalk so no idea what yours is - if it is a dead horse, how apt.