Each to their own and I would never expect those in one camp to support the other - unbiased and unconscious bias kick in - we are only human after all, but let me add my 2 cents
I’ve had a few RS3’s - two 8P’s and they were awesome all round and still are.
My PFL has sports exhaust and was simply different class sound wise. Then I put Aoon’s decat Pipes on and I was in heaven - the best sound I have ever had on a car and a quick switch to comfort put me back in stealth mode - nothing quite like it if you have experienced (unless of course you live upward to the likes of RS6 land ).
Anyway I was tempted with VC and all the other FL updates and even though I loved my SB I thought it would be nice to have a saloon - so I started to research and quickly noted on the engine, turbo and front end weigh changes as well as overall handling and as I have always modded I was really intrigued by the FL’s 500bhp potential and low 3s 0-60 from a modest and relatively safe expense - so I bit the bullet and went saloon, mythos, black optic, titanium upgrade wheels, SSS, RS pack, carbon pack, light pack, delimiter 174, sports exhaust, mag ride, B & O and tonnes of other stuff that I can’t remember and have also increased her bhp when she hit 1k miles. I am now at 2.5k and I can honestly say this car launches faster than anything I have ever came across and the handling is improved but for my style of driving - which formme
Is spirited - it’s not night and day....maybe night and dusk
To the point in Q, the FL sports exhaust is without doubt much quieter than the PFL although does come to incredible life when in the zone as as many have already done - possibly because they miss the PFL sound - have tampered with the valve flaps.
The next Q to ask yourself though in this debate is if you could, would you change your FL exhaust to a PFL - my answer would be 100% YES and I would even pay an extra grand if I could have a magic wand to hand!
Don’t get me wrong I love my FL saloon and wouldn’t swap her, but if I could bring back that “simply lovely” zorst note of my PFL I would - it’s like losing a finger or something - in fact if I could deal now and put a lot of my other options on the table for that hypothetical swap it would already be a done deal as in my opinion nothing is as satisfying as that PFL, sports, decat, dynamic mode thrill - it’s ecstacy!!!
But for me the real question is why on earth did Audi change it in the first place? That for me was a backward step from FL to PFL - at least offer customers the option?!?
Sorry for the long winded reply but got engrossed in this thread over a