1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Something doesn't add up here

galashan Sep 22, 2013

  1. galashan

    galashan New Member

    I took my car to a garage to get my mot done, they passed the car and said i had a oil leak that needed sorting so i asked them how much and they quoted me around 70-80 to get it fixed.

    So i got them to sort out the problem with the oil leak, they rang the same day saying that it was now going to cost close to 400 to get it sorted due to them finding that it was actually a cracked oil filter housing and i needed a new breather pipe as well, so i figured ok fine get it sorted.

    They called me the following day to come pick the car up as its all done, i went to collect the car and got not even 1/2 mile down the road and the Oil Pressure Warning light came on so obviously i took the car straight back to the garage, i left it with them and they called the next day now stating that the oil pump had gone, but it seems to me they are just trying to cover there arses and they damaged something on the oil filter housing job and now trying to get me to pay for their cock-up.

    Apparently they now say i need a new big end part and also a new strainer as they found metal in the strainer and they said that the thrust bearer on the pump had shattered.

    surely the oil pump is nowhere near the oil filter housing and why on earth would they need to go looking at the big end as well it all sounds a bit fishy to me, just sounds like they have messed up and are trying to get money for nothing.

    The car before it went in the garage never had any oil pressure issues at all and i always checked the oil regularly but when it comes out it has oil pressure problems, doesn't sound right to me

    all advice/thoughts would be great as i know not much about cars and just dont want to be ripped off bigtime and left with a useless car that aint worth ****.

    also how much would a oil pump cost as they quoted me a crazy price
    Last edited: Sep 22, 2013
  2. tdi-man

    tdi-man Well-Known Member

    what engine do you have ?
  3. galashan

    galashan New Member

    its a audi a3 2.0 fsi sportback 8pa
  4. chris.vincent3

    chris.vincent3 Own a BMW now, HOWEVER I still own VCDS! VCDS Map User

    Ask to see such parts that have apparently failed.
  5. MartayMcFly

    MartayMcFly Booooooost VCDS Map User Gold Supporter

    Surely any issue with the pump would have been picked when they checked over the system or when they test drove the car after the first round of work, sounds dodgy that you only made it 1/2 a mile before losing oil pressure. Either they did a very poor repair job, or did damage somehow and thought/hoped you'd get further before you realised.
  6. galashan

    galashan New Member

    they said they had it on the ramps running in idle for 90 mins but never took it out for a drive, but this does all sound very dodgy to me
  7. mjr901

    mjr901 Guest Gold Supporter Audi S3

    I'd also ask for some more fuel!! 90mins is well excessive!!!

    With any part, replace, then road test, then re check for leaks etc.

    Obviously a cooling issue may be a different story, and not related to this one!
  8. galashan

    galashan New Member

    yeah 90 mins is excessive
  9. Fanboy

    Fanboy An Audi Fanboy

    Sorry to hear this...

    Did you log the mileage before hand, obviuosly all of these garages are bloody rip-offs, well personally happened to me twice before and tried blooding ripping me off for silly stuff...

    I believe when making a change to any of the components, they get logged in the ECU... or I may be wrong, but double check these with another mechanic/garage! Probably your usual garage which used before these guys would be ideal!

    Anyway good luck and hope you get it sorted ASAP! :)
  10. bmh.01

    bmh.01 Member

    You're wrong, the ecu will no have record of 99% of things being changed.
  11. Artimus

    Artimus Shortback

    That's sickening! I hate hearing stories of Garages ripping people off. Name & Shame them. They broke your car & they need to fix it or pay someone that knows what they're doing to fix it. Make sure you let them know there were no issues before they breathed on it & you'll report the incident to trading standards.

    I personally never get MOT advisories repaired at the same garage that issued them, as it leaves too much room for ambiguity & dollar signs start popping up. ALWAYS ALWAYS get a second opinion before getting "recommended" work done.
  12. T8DPR

    T8DPR If Carlsberg Made Audi Drivers...


    If they've disposed of them, tell them you can report them for theft as you still own them, and in this case definitely need them
  13. MartayMcFly

    MartayMcFly Booooooost VCDS Map User Gold Supporter

    I know most cars don't like warming up at idle, something to do with how the oil circulates... surely sat for 90mins would be even worse, especially since it was an oil issue they were fixing.

Share This Page