1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

s3 or R32

alexA3 Nov 19, 2012

  1. alexA3

    alexA3 New Member

    13
    1
    3
    Evening all,

    I am 21 years old and in the position to spend up to 13k on a car. To begin with I was going to be sensible and get a newish diesel a3. But seeing as I'm living at home for the next few years I thought i might swell get a high performance car whilst I can.

    I can't decide between a mk5 DPB r32 or a 06/07 S3. I am kinda swaying towards the r32 because they are a fair bit cheaper to buy and love the sound of the v6. However, i much prefer the interior and exterior of the s3.

    What would you chaps recommend? Is there much difference in running costs? Insurance is pretty much the same on both cars.

    Cheers
     
  2. S3Alex

    S3Alex Rarely neutral Team Ibis TFSI Owners Group Gold Supporter Audi S3 DSG

    10,579
    4,646
    113
    Well done.....when I was your age I could afford a heap of rust!
    Joking aside,I think the S3 is probably the best overall choice,as you can remap it,and unlock a lot of potential,but it's also easier on fuel.....yes,the R32 sounds a lot nicer,but from owning both an S3,and an A3 3.2,I know which I'd choose.
     
  3. AndyParker

    AndyParker Active Member

    320
    48
    28
    If you plan on spending any money on modifying the engine then S3 has got to be the way forwards unless you're willing to spend 6k-10k getting the R32 supercharged/turbo'd.

    Yes the R32 does sound awesome but gains are going to be poor in comparison.

    just went through the same dilemma as you and landed on the S3 side
     
  4. MartayMcFly

    MartayMcFly Booooooost Regional Rep VCDS Map User Gold Supporter

    2,749
    352
    83
    R32 sounds better, S3 wins at everything else.
     
  5. alexA3

    alexA3 New Member

    13
    1
    3

    I really can't decide. TBH I'm not really that bothered about modding it. A black edition grill and some nice alloys would do me nicely.

    You happy with the s3? I want to get one before christmas so need to make my mind up.
     
  6. mjr901

    mjr901 Guest Gold Supporter Audi S3

    3,595
    1,062
    113
    You'll get the 'power' bug and you'll want more.

    R32 - realistically Un-tunable. It's nice though.

    S3 - makes a louder noise with the right exhaust! + better on fuel + faster out of the box.

    Dont be daft, use YouTube for R32 noises and then jump in the S3
     
    MartayMcFly likes this.
  7. AndyParker

    AndyParker Active Member

    320
    48
    28
    Really pleased with the S3. I came from a Mini JCW and the R32 was the same kind of speed and I wanted something faster so opted for the S3. Cannot fault it thus far.

    You say you're not into modding it but for the sake of £400 on a remap you can add an extra 50bhp taking it to 310/315 bhp. The same bang for buck isn't achievable on the R32

    Plus your ongoing fuel costs and Tax are more expensive in the R32

    :s3addict:
     
  8. Ben S3 8P3

    Ben S3 8P3 Member

    313
    32
    18
    Tax on an R32 is 480 quid a year. Which I couldnt justify
     
  9. GNJ_Motorsport

    GNJ_Motorsport Site Sponsor Site Sponsor

    660
    188
    43
    Pretty much sums it up perfectly :)
     
    MartayMcFly likes this.
  10. deanshaw24

    deanshaw24 Well-Known Member

    530
    438
    63
    ^ second that
     
  11. Don's A3 TTu

    Don's A3 TTu Member

    317
    5
    18
    or just meet in the middle and do what i did i got the best of both worlds
     
  12. essIII

    essIII Active Member

    285
    35
    28
    This.
     
  13. I oOEddOo I

    I oOEddOo I Member

    340
    15
    18
    S3 all the way
     
  14. Sheikh

    Sheikh Member

    654
    20
    16
  15. wuta3

    wuta3 Well-Known Member

    1,124
    347
    83
    Pppfffttt S3 all the way, I was in a similar position (3.2 vs 2.0T) and test drove many. While the 3.2 does sound epic, it's a silly option IMVHO
     
  16. tedward

    tedward Member

    166
    1
    16
    get an R32 while you have disposable income and just enjoy the noise. you can have the more sensible S3 when you are older and a bit more boring!

    You wont get away with the noise an R32 makes with a mr's and nippers on board in a few years!

    I have owned V6 golf's and driven S3's and would have another V6 golf in a heart beat.

    The golfs make the S3 look overpriced.
     
  17. essIII

    essIII Active Member

    285
    35
    28
    Lol, apart from the fact that the Golf R is currently more expensive than an S3, even though it's essentially the same car.
     
  18. c_w

    c_w Well-Known Member

    1,163
    87
    48
    Golf R isn't a V6. The comparison is obviously for older R32s vs S3s
     
  19. Audi Dynamik

    Audi Dynamik Well-Known Member

    2,218
    308
    83
    The s3 is lighter quicker better on fuel cheaper tax much better looking
    :s3addict: all the way
     
    MartayMcFly likes this.
  20. essIII

    essIII Active Member

    285
    35
    28
    The comparison was clear. "Golfs make the S3 look overpriced".
     
  21. c_w

    c_w Well-Known Member

    1,163
    87
    48
    Only out of context. You have also mis-quoted removing the word "the".

    In the context of this thread, the OP has £13k to spend on an S3 or R32, ergo we are talking these older cars 5yrs old or so. For your money you're going to get more with the Golf (newer/less miles perhaps). HTH.
     
    Last edited: Nov 20, 2012
  22. RedDejavu

    RedDejavu Well-Known Member

    1,802
    333
    83
    You dont win by the noise from the lights tbh:]
     
  23. big harty

    big harty Member

    307
    15
    16
    S3 all the way. R32 sound nice but are slow compared to s3.
     
  24. rOb_A

    rOb_A Active Member

    1,488
    63
    36
    think about the people you are asking............. :laugh:

    this should sum it up :kissmyrings:
     
  25. tcardio

    tcardio Well-Known Member

    957
    272
    63
    my 0.02...MKIV R32 is the only "R" in my book. If you have to chose between MKV and S3, it's easy...S3
     
  26. tedward

    tedward Member

    166
    1
    16
    I never really have understood why the mk4 R32 holds more weight in vag circles than the newer mk5?

    Personally think the mk5 in the right colour, leather buckets and right wheels is a lovely thing.

    It's not all about outright speed, at cruising speed the noise of an R32 is gorgeous.
     
  27. Ste_Nova

    Ste_Nova Active Member

    1,223
    47
    38
    buy the r32, turbo it in 12months time
     
  28. RedDejavu

    RedDejavu Well-Known Member

    1,802
    333
    83
    For the money you could have got S3 stage2+ easily:]
     
  29. euphoria

    euphoria New Member

    22
    0
    1
    S3 S3 S3!

    I moved out last year, and have decided on a sensible A3 2.0 TDI 140, still pretty quick and comfy tho! - if i was living at home, it would have been an S3 for sure :p
    Drive the audi and see what you think! I personally love the interior and exterior of the A/S3, the golf does nothing for me!
     
  30. voorhees

    voorhees Moderator Staff Member Moderator DSG

    16,132
    1,971
    113
  31. grr666

    grr666 Member

    171
    19
    16
    I had same dilemma, went for S3.
    Cheaper road tax, better mpg, but quicker and lighter and much easier to get
    extra power out of the engine.
    No brainer really.
     
  32. mjr901

    mjr901 Guest Gold Supporter Audi S3

    3,595
    1,062
    113
    Have you considered the Edition 30 golf? Same engine as the S3, less the 4wd. Map it, 360bhp. Lots of drama which the S3 lacks.

    Better on fuel as no 4wd, cheaper, lighter aswell.
     
  33. RedDejavu

    RedDejavu Well-Known Member

    1,802
    333
    83
    ED30 is not the same engine same turbo though.
     
  34. -Ju-

    -Ju- Well-Known Member VCDS Map User Team Panther Audi S3

    2,193
    377
    83
    I had 2 A3 3.2 dsg's before the S3 and even after remapping the S3, I still missed the noise and drivability of the 3.2. After 12 months I traded the S3 in and bought an R36.
    I just found that most of todays driving is done at realistic speeds in mostly traffic dominated situations and for that the bigger engine in the R, especially with dsg, was more suited overall to everyday driving.
    Best to try both out first for yourself tbh and then make your own mind up as ultimately it's a personal choice.
    It's a nice situation to be in though at your age!
     
  35. Ste_Nova

    Ste_Nova Active Member

    1,223
    47
    38
    really? on my 17th birthday i stuck L plates on 10k worth of brand new nova lol
     
  36. tedward

    tedward Member

    166
    1
    16
    £10 grand? Were they ever that much? Must have ticked all the boxes on that one?
     
  37. mjr901

    mjr901 Guest Gold Supporter Audi S3

    3,595
    1,062
    113
    Yes, not the exact the same engine then...it may as well be though.

    They are very VERY similiar, largely just de-tuned.

    Edition 30 is just as tune-able as the S3, up to stage 2+ with the only thing needing to be changed is the intercooler.

    Quite often the edition 30's cream the S3's on the 1/4 mile too.

    It has..

    * Larger Turbo from S3 (K04) rather then the K03 on the GTI
    * 87°C thermostat instead of 80°C
    * Larger capacity fuel injectors (13% higher flow)
    * Larger intercooler (smaller then the S3)
    * Engine block main bearing caps, pedestals are reinforced
    * Conrods have larger rod bolts and new bearings
    * Pistons have 21mm gudgeon pins instead of 19mm
    * Piston top ring is improved
    * Recirculation Valve (blow off valve) not located on turbo


    The Audi S3 and the Edition 30/Pirelli/Seat Leon Cupra R share the same short block, same turbo and similar intercooler.

    have a read...2.0TFSi engines? - PistonHeads

    Yes the camshaft is different and the S3 block is slightly more re-inforced, the edition 30 has proven just as strong in reality.

    personally I gotta have the 4wd, it feels good. :)
     
    Last edited: Nov 21, 2012
  38. grr666

    grr666 Member

    171
    19
    16
    That's exactly what I thought but I'm too much of a noob here to come out and
    state that directly. I thought the S3 had stronger internals and a different head which
    dissipates heat better. The ED30 is similar but not the same.
    Again it was another car on my 'might buy' list before buying the S3.
    At 40 years of age I'm not after a car that lights up the front wheels at the drop of a dime.
    My last car did that all too easily and it's drama (and understeer) I could do without tbh.
    It was okay in the dry but in the wet/cold it was very hard to get the power down.
     
  39. RedDejavu

    RedDejavu Well-Known Member

    1,802
    333
    83
    Good info that, and yes 4wd wins it for me too its just so good:]
     
  40. Ste_Nova

    Ste_Nova Active Member

    1,223
    47
    38
    there were only 4 boxes you could tick!! mats/flaps/headlight protectors/dog guard!
     

Share This Page