1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Rust on my roof rails has returned!

Westy Sep 14, 2009

  1. Westy

    Westy Well-Known Member

    17,443
    1,105
    113
    While washing my car over the weekend I noticed that the bubbling of rust has returned to my passenger side roof rail less than 4 months after having it treated and resprayed!

    Some of you may be aware that I had my rust and paint work done by an independant garrage after my anti corrosion claim was rejected by Audi due to the car already being sprayed down the passenger side.

    Has anyone else had theirs fixed and noticed the rust return? Does anyone know the best way to treat this issue so that it doesn't keep returning? I dont fany forking out £200 every 4 months!
     
  2. jojo

    jojo Looking for Boost! Staff Member Moderator Team Daytona Audi S3 quattro Audi A6 Audi Avant Owner Group

    28,942
    3,597
    113
    Take it back!
     
  3. Broken Byzan

    Broken Byzan Photographic Moderator Staff Member Moderator VCDS Map User quattro Audi A4

    13,237
    465
    83
    That sucks, as Joe says tho, be nice and take it back.

    Can the roof rails be removed and replaced?
     
  4. S3 HODGE

    S3 HODGE Brown passenger seat.

    1,200
    1
    38
    Thats no good, As said below take it back and ask for it to be done again.

    Yep you can pull the rails out and replace them, Also when they are out there will be no affects (Water leaking though etc).
     
  5. Broken Byzan

    Broken Byzan Photographic Moderator Staff Member Moderator VCDS Map User quattro Audi A4

    13,237
    465
    83
    So why do they treat the rust than replace and paint? Cost? As our A3 has signs of this, but obv been fully resprayed so would no doubt get rejected
     
  6. Westy

    Westy Well-Known Member

    17,443
    1,105
    113
    I will be taking it back to see what they say. The guy who did it is a life long mate of my girlfriends step dad so he did it for a nice price cash in hand. I bought a brand new rail which he put in because the old one was bent where it had been out before and just reused.

    I was kind of expecting the rust to resurface again at some point but not after 4 months!
     
  7. cjhill

    cjhill hmmmmm interesting.

    335
    0
    16
    hmmm.. ive had similar problems,

    Had both sides done 2-3 years ago (under warranty by audi), both sides have been redone again since then and now its back for a 3rd time....

    really getting annoyed now.

    I know the car is now 8 years old but the rest of the body / paintwork is like new and its not like i haven't looked after the car.

    Really annoyed.
     
  8. cjhill

    cjhill hmmmmm interesting.

    335
    0
    16
    did i say i was annoyed...?
     
  9. Westy

    Westy Well-Known Member

    17,443
    1,105
    113
    That is annoying mate you must be well annoyed!

    Its a bit bad that you have to spend out on getting the roof re-done every few months, can get very costly.
     
  10. nak

    nak New Member

    28
    0
    1
    What would the consequence be, if you just had old roof rails taken out and filled, leaving you with a smooth roof :think:
     
  11. Westy

    Westy Well-Known Member

    17,443
    1,105
    113
    The rust itself isn't actually on the rail as I believe that's aluminium. The rust tends to appear on the part of roof just outside the rail.

    I think if the rails were filled it would look pony, and it wouldn't necessarily stop the rust from coming back.
     
  12. cjhill

    cjhill hmmmmm interesting.

    335
    0
    16
    hmmm, took it to the same garage and its booked in for another (3rd) repair. Haven't paid a penny so far in any of these repairs so its just inconvenient.

    This time they didnt even come out to see the car - just said (in a disheartened manor, followed by a sigh) sure well book it in again and do it. We've had loads of these...
     
  13. Westy

    Westy Well-Known Member

    17,443
    1,105
    113
    Bit annoying isn't it. Did you have a new rail fitted every time or just reuse the same one?

    I'll be visiting the garage soon to discuss with them but i'm not convinced they're going to fix it for free.
     
  14. nak

    nak New Member

    28
    0
    1
    I was told that once old rail comes out, new one's have to be put in place, for it's not that easy fetching them out and basically they bend and if you do manage to use the old ones, never sit right in groove.
     
    Last edited: Sep 17, 2009
  15. cjhill

    cjhill hmmmmm interesting.

    335
    0
    16
    the old rails should be fine, they come out easily. I remove mine twice a year just to keep an eye on the rust problem.

    just dont go mad and take them out carefully.
     
  16. Westy

    Westy Well-Known Member

    17,443
    1,105
    113
    I only replaced my old one because it was bent from the last time it had been out. I'll make sure the body shop take it out carefully when they re do it.
     
  17. rusty s3

    rusty s3 Member

    64
    0
    6
    if you have no luck with your body shop i work for a body shop in enfield quite close to you and im sure we could sort it out for you?pm me.
     
  18. Westy

    Westy Well-Known Member

    17,443
    1,105
    113
    Going by your name i'd say your body shop was unable to fix your paintwork :moa:

    Only kidding. If I dont get anywhere with my place I'll PM you. Many thanks.
     
  19. Lyntonius

    Lyntonius New Member

    17
    0
    1
    Uhhnn... this is kinda disheartening. Having my S3 go into the bodyshop in a couple of weeks to have this fixed, from what I know, for the first time. The guy at the shop said it happens because of the way they're assembled; ie. they paint everything, and then putting the actual rails in is enough to scratch the paint, and that in conjunction with small amounts of water getting in under the rail causes it to happen.

    What do you guys think of that theory? I asked him if he can primer/rust proof the hell out of it before putting them in, he said odds are it will come back.

    Sadface.
     
  20. Westy

    Westy Well-Known Member

    17,443
    1,105
    113
    it is disheartening mate. I kind of expected it to come back maybe in a year or two but not in 3 and half months!!! :banghead:

    I never thought id be figghting with rust on a 7 year old Audi! I used to own a 16 year old Renault and never had any issues with rust!
     
  21. millwrx

    millwrx Member

    223
    0
    16
    had my rust done on the roof and the bottom of the quarters by the audi dealer 2/3 years ago and the rust spot has come back on the quarter,cars a w reg,not taking it back and will live with it as they would not do it a second time i would have thought,the only real way off getting rid of rust is to cut it out,you wont stop it once it is in the panel,bummer i know
     
  22. cjhill

    cjhill hmmmmm interesting.

    335
    0
    16
    the body shop i have taken mine to is an approved audi / VW one (think its actually run by the same group as the main dealer).

    They say they have seen millions of roof rails going on all sorts of VAG cars - lupo's, golfs, a3's etc.

    The roof is aluminum but the side stripes (which form part of the rear quarter / A post etc) are steel. Where they are joined and sealed is where the water gets in. Rubbish design if you ask me.
     
  23. Lyntonius

    Lyntonius New Member

    17
    0
    1
    Sooo... how can we stop this from coming back? Any thoughts?
     
  24. Westy

    Westy Well-Known Member

    17,443
    1,105
    113
    I thinking that the only way to stop the rust once its in the rear quater is to have it cut out but that wont be cheap.

    The body shop I used want me to pay them again to do the work and I dont think they did a very good job so I'm not going to them again!

    I'm going to get a few quotes done and ask around for a possible solution.

    The 8L S3 has such a cult following and no doubt will be classed as a classic car in years to come. Unfortunately it will be remembered by most as a rust bucket :blownose:
     
  25. nik patel

    nik patel Member

    243
    15
    18
    They should have a paintwork warranty, most bodyshops have at least 2 years, i would send it back
     
  26. Westy

    Westy Well-Known Member

    17,443
    1,105
    113
    No bodyshop would give me a warrenty because the rear quarter had already been repaired! I'm going to visit the audi recommend one next time but they're not cheap!
     
  27. liquidsmoke

    liquidsmoke New Member

    2
    0
    1
    Hi,
    Silly question perhaps - but how do I get the rails out? I want to have a go at treating the rust on my car before it gets bad.
     
  28. s3dave

    s3dave TFSI Hybrid Supporter

    10,110
    736
    38
    They are just pushed in...
     
  29. 16Klappe

    16Klappe I <3 Panda's! Supporter

    5,795
    1,186
    113
    What age is your car?

    Audi have a 12 year anti corrosion warranty, and there is a HUGE thread on here which shows the actions you need to take and probable outcomes.
     
  30. S321BAM

    S321BAM I lost the rod lottery

    124
    24
    18
    I claimed through audi, came back a yr later, complained and they sorted it again for me. Take it back
     
  31. sportquattro

    sportquattro Active Member

    845
    51
    28
    Had my roof corrosion sorted by Audi's approved repairer in Plymouth 3.5 years ago and touch wood no signs of it returning. If yours was done 4 moths ago I'd suggest that it's not of merchantable quality and under sale of goods act they should redo it.

    Good luck with it
    Nige
     

Share This Page