I Currently have pilot sport 3 michelin - probably from factory done 64k miles now. Noticed today front passenger tyre in bad condition and rear tyre already has bad wall and puncture repaired 6 months back. I think it is time to get all 4 new tyres (Quattro 2.0T FSI) 235/40 ZR 18 95Y currently installed. P Zeros are a popular choice Dunlop SP Sport Maxx RT Michelin Pilot Sport 3 - what ones shall I get though? Should I get the same rating as well?