1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

KandN or Pipercross filter

dale86 Feb 16, 2014

  1. dale86

    dale86 Member

    452
    15
    18
    Hi just wondering which panel filter to go for as I need a new one anyway so just wanting peoples opinions and experience. I know people say they don't make any difference but I'm just gona get one anyway lol. Thanks in advance
     
  2. S4_dan

    S4_dan Fire up the Quattro! VCDS Map User

    2,741
    165
    63
    K&N, Green Cotton & Pipercross are what i've used in the past. To be honest, the Pipercross induction filter gives an awesome noise due to the foam structure. But induction kits tend to kill MAFs.....
     
  3. Jim_P

    Jim_P Member

    38
    6
    8
    I run a BMC panel filter, have only used BMC in my previous cars also and they are spot on. Extremely good quality. I take mine out every 6k or so and give it a clean and pop it back in. :)
     
  4. dale86

    dale86 Member

    452
    15
    18
    That's the only thing putting me off is if it kills my air flow meter bit isn't that to do with if you over oil them or is it just because of the amount of extra air flow. I'm tempted to go for pipercross has anyone had a filter damage their MAF or is this just down to the MAF all ready been on the way out as it is fairly common fault anyway as I have all ready replaced mine for a new Bosch item.
     
  5. minimadmotorman

    minimadmotorman Member

    189
    10
    18
    For me just a standard paper Mahle item.
     
  6. S4_dan

    S4_dan Fire up the Quattro! VCDS Map User

    2,741
    165
    63
    It's mainly the induction kits that are pre-oiled and require oiling after a clean.

    Panel filters tend to be dryer.....
     
  7. desertstorm

    desertstorm Moderator Staff Member Moderator VCDS Map User quattro Audi A4 Audi Avant Owner Group TDi

    5,896
    2,701
    113
    Just fit OE filter, the only difference with K and N and similar is they cost more and the oiled ones screw up the MAF if slightly overoiled.
    Also the performance ones don't filter as well. There is no difference on a dyno,
    When I was on the dyno with my 130 TDI Passat I took the OE filter with 10K miles on it out, and ran it without a filter. On a 200bhp car it made about 1bhp and 4Lb/ft of torque more.
    I cut apart an old air filter and stretched it out on the drive, it was 28ft long.

    [​IMG]

    Karl.
     
  8. dale86

    dale86 Member

    452
    15
    18
    Thanks all I be ordered a pipercross panel filter I'll see how it performs and if its naff I'll revert back to standard one thanks for your input it's really helpfull.
     
  9. S4_dan

    S4_dan Fire up the Quattro! VCDS Map User

    2,741
    165
    63
    WOW! Were you bored? lol. That's pretty impressive though, the length of the filter laid out!

    Dan
     
  10. mattyboyc

    mattyboyc B6 Veteran Audi A4 Audi Avant Owner Group TDi

    1,998
    218
    63
    I have used both OE and pipercross and in my experience it made no noticeable difference at all only pipercross cost 3 times as much.
     
  11. deano1978

    deano1978 different gear

    713
    81
    28
    I found pipercross poor quality,rubbers seams around edges came apart.
     
  12. dale86

    dale86 Member

    452
    15
    18
    The pipercross I've ordered states it has a lifetime warranty so any issues I'm sure I'll take up with pipercross I hope their isn't any though lol.
     
  13. deano1978

    deano1978 different gear

    713
    81
    28
    Saying that,i should of checked mine. Got it off the bay.
     
  14. Mike.M

    Mike.M Well-Known Member

    2,510
    170
    63
    Got a K&N panel filter for sale in the classifieds if anyone is interested.......5k miles use and £25 delivered.

    Removed from car when I bought it as prefer the paper filter being a TDI
     
  15. Olibb

    Olibb New Member

    9
    0
    1
    Let me know if you get any increased intake noise. My turbo on my BEX is almost silent! Id like more of a noise; but dont want to run an open cone filter.
     
  16. morrisonbrink

    morrisonbrink Member

    67
    33
    18
    My car came with a pipercross filter..... and a near dead MAF
     
  17. Chrismawa

    Chrismawa Active Member

    457
    46
    28
    OEM all the way!
     
  18. AudiLeon

    AudiLeon Well-Known Member VCDS Map User

    2,250
    192
    63
    Genuine paper.
     
  19. Mike.M

    Mike.M Well-Known Member

    2,510
    170
    63
    The K&N I took out of mine was fine but my car just did not like it too much.
     
  20. dale86

    dale86 Member

    452
    15
    18
    What do you mean by not liking it were there symptoms just incase mine starts getting any.
     
  21. vwgtiking

    vwgtiking Active Member

    1,030
    8
    38
    DAle. Update?
     
  22. DieselJake

    DieselJake Well-Known Member

    2,902
    725
    113
    Update is me and Dale need to see who has the fastest 1.9tdi :happy:
     
    deano1978 likes this.
  23. dale86

    dale86 Member

    452
    15
    18
    Ha ha ha I'm just waiting on getting it mapped now and I should of listened and just gone for a standard paper filter as the pipercross hasn't made any noticeably difference not even in sound .
     
  24. Mike.M

    Mike.M Well-Known Member

    2,510
    170
    63
    Sorry noticed this. Mine started to burn more oil with it in oddly. When I put the OEM paper version back in oil consumption disappeared.

    Odd I know but it happened on my engine and always used K&N in past cars without issues.

    Sound wise the K&N filter made the turbo blow off louder than the paper.
     
  25. vwgtiking

    vwgtiking Active Member

    1,030
    8
    38
    So basicAlly stick with oem. In USA they have a brand called afe which doesn't use oil but sounds like the k&n.
     

Share This Page