1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Help me Choose VW Golf GTD or Audi a3 sportback

imran999 Mar 10, 2014

  1. imran999

    imran999 New Member

    24
    1
    1
    Which is the better option?

    AUDI A3 2.0 TDI 150ps Sport diesel sportback
    or
    VW Golf GTD 5dr 2.0TDI 184ps

    Purchasing on personal lease finance,
    The audi will cost me total of £7134 over 2 yrs
    and the golf is costing slightly more at £7308 over 2yrs

    Both cars will be in their standard forms i.e no additional options.

    So which is the better car in standard form?
     
  2. mjcourtney

    mjcourtney Well-Known Member Team Mythos Audi A4 Audi Avant Owner Group S-line owners group TDi

    1,659
    509
    113
    If you're just looking for value for money then the Golf wins, as the GTD spec has much better equipment as standard when compared to an A3 Sport.

    However, if you want the Audi badge and, in my opinion, a better looking car - go for the A3.
     
  3. cemerson

    cemerson Well-Known Member Team Cosmos quattro Audi A3 S-line owners group TDi DSG

    4,479
    1,124
    113
    Nicer interior and better infotainment system in the Audi IMO as well. Only you know what your priorities are though, or what you are or aren't bothered about!
     
  4. imran999

    imran999 New Member

    24
    1
    1
    Currently drive a A4 Saloon 2.0TFSI S-line Quattro B7 model, so I am needing to downsize due to finances.

    car is Used mainly for the 40 mile round trip daily to and from work.

    How does the 150 compare to the 184 engine?
     
  5. cemerson

    cemerson Well-Known Member Team Cosmos quattro Audi A3 S-line owners group TDi DSG

    4,479
    1,124
    113
    I've not driven both, but I find the 150 engine great - plenty of power, more than enough to overtake most of the time. I probably would have gone for the 184 had it been available at the time, but it wasn't and the extra wait wasn't worth it for me.
     
  6. snakehips

    snakehips Well-Known Member

    735
    261
    63
    Why not compare them with the same 184PS engine?
    I came from a GTi but when the time came to replace it I found that the A3 was such a nicer place to sit than the Golf. That was pretty much the only reason for switching, along with availability of B&O stereo.
     
  7. Migwire

    Migwire Active Member

    393
    125
    43
    Having picked up a 184PS A3 on Friday I have to say the engine is a real cracker! Pulls from around 1700rpm and is so refined you'd be forgiven for thinking it's a petrol. It makes for effortless overtaking. As for the A3 itself, oh what a real class act!! A quality piece of engineering if ever I saw one!
     
    steeve and cemerson like this.
  8. imran999

    imran999 New Member

    24
    1
    1
    For some reason the finance company are pricing the a3 tdi 184 model at over 2.3k higher over the 2 years hence I am looking at the 2 comparables in prices.

    I've been an Audi customer for the last 10 yrs and love the interiors....so I am just wondering if theres anything Im missing by not going for the GTD.
     
  9. s3_trev

    s3_trev Northern Ireland Gold Supporter Audi S3 Team Brill Red

    1,854
    631
    113
    Id go for the Golf. Much nicer looking car IMO, can take the 5 doors without the stretched out look of the sportback.
     
  10. Trickz

    Trickz New Member

    29
    0
    1
    Go for the golf,I cancelled my s3 sportback order and have gone for a golf r,yes the audi has a better interior but the options are pricey and although the s3 came with leather as standard it took £2100 of options to spec it like the r,but the main reason is the r has steering feeling and it doesn't understeer like a vectra! Even though it shares nearly all the s3 parts,weird.
     
  11. thedooker

    thedooker Active Member

    156
    134
    43
    My mate has just ordered a Golf R - he asked me to jump straight from my S3 and test the R back to back. I found the steering in the golf slightly worse than the S3 in dynamic mode. As for the way it handle it was damned near identical. If I didn't look down at the golf's cheaper looking dash I would have struggled to tell the difference! Still a great car though.
     
  12. Trickz

    Trickz New Member

    29
    0
    1
    Thinking about it it was probably down to the tyres that made the golf feel better on my test drive anyway,the golf had Bridgestone's on and I think the s3 had conti's
     
  13. snakehips

    snakehips Well-Known Member

    735
    261
    63
    In that case definitely go for the Golf. More bang for your buck and the Golf is generally more highly rated anyway.
     
  14. M_D_O_London

    M_D_O_London Active Member

    140
    44
    28
    I'd probably say the GTD. It's a smart looking car and comes with a lot of equipment that is optional on the A3 including:

    * Elec folding mirrors
    * Auto Lights, Wipers, Coming home / leaving home lighting, Adaptive Cruise
    * Xenon Headlights
    * Tinted windows (B-pillar back)
    * 18' Alloy Wheels
    * Tyre pressure monitoring

    Quality-wise, the A3 is certainly better (no doubt) but for max bang for your buck, it'd have to be the Golf.
     
  15. steeve

    steeve Well-Known Member TeamMisano Team Ibis Audi S3

    2,701
    1,518
    113
    On those two? I'd go for the Golf, the engine would make the difference for me.
     
  16. arad85

    arad85 Active Member Team V6 Audi S5 Black Edition

    675
    195
    43
    If those are the twop options and you're OK with the Golf interior, then the Golf, no question.
     
  17. Daz Auto

    Daz Auto Active Member

    583
    150
    43
    The A3 Saloon 150ps would be similar in style to your current car. It is the best looking in my opinion.

    The Golf is a bigger car if you need the size.

    If money is such a factor - then have a looked at a Golf GT 150ps. Surely that will save even more money.

    I have the old GTD. Would not buy another one unless they have made it more comfortable - with the move to 18 inch tyres - I doubt that.
     
  18. Avallon

    Avallon New Member

    11
    0
    1
    Or....if 2 seats are sufficient and you can stretch your budget a little bit, for £300 p/m + £900 initially you can get an SLK 250 CDI roadster...?
     
  19. PilotAudi

    PilotAudi New Member

    2,352
    479
    0
    Why would anyone want M-B rubbish rather than an Audi??
     
    Last edited: Mar 13, 2014

Share This Page