1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

BP Ultimate or Shell V-Power?

Cruiser89 Dec 7, 2011

?

What do you prefer?

  1. BP Ultimate

    5.0%
  2. Shell V-Power

    95.0%
  1. Cruiser89

    Cruiser89 Advanced In Car Tech Site Sponsor

    1,484
    222
    63
    Hey guys,

    Decided I want to use a better quality fuel in the new car. Which one do you use / prefer and why...

    Does it really make much of a difference?

    Ta much...
     
  2. Spin140

    Spin140 Well-Known Member

    2,196
    186
    63
    Tesco 99 is my usual flavour based purely on convenience, nearest Shell is 8 miles away.
     
  3. FranA3

    FranA3 FMDETAILING Regional Rep Site Sponsor Gold Supporter Audi A3 Team Brill Red

    7,236
    331
    83
    mine too , not because of the convenience thing because around by me its cheaper by 9p per litre
     
  4. Cruiser89

    Cruiser89 Advanced In Car Tech Site Sponsor

    1,484
    222
    63
    Does it give the same sort of extra benefits as it would if it was Shell or BP?
     
  5. Shadowman

    Shadowman Active Member

    592
    43
    28
    Have to be honest....I have only ever used either V-Power or Ultimate in all my Audi's.

    I figure we spend so much on the car, and then either 'modding' it or keeping it on the road that it would be a bit silly in my opinion to then put cheap fuel in it.

    Maybe i just believe the hype, but I've seen enough tests of premium fuels v cheap fuels to get comfort that the extra cost of premium fuels is worth paying.......I wouldn't get myself in top physical shape and then eat **** food....it's the same principal !! ( actually, I just wouldn't get myself in top physical shape :))
     
  6. markie A3

    markie A3 Member

    149
    3
    16
    I might be wrong, but back when I had my scooby, im sure it was posted on scoobynet, that Tesco fuels are ESSO??
     
  7. FranA3

    FranA3 FMDETAILING Regional Rep Site Sponsor Gold Supporter Audi A3 Team Brill Red

    7,236
    331
    83
    yeah i think so mate its 99 octane so it gives a small increase in power but it makes my engine run so much smoother it was a little lumpy on idle on tesco99 its fine also i get a good increase in mpg too , but i do run a tank of shell in her every 5 tanks of tesco99 as its got really good cleaning qualities in it , i know my car is only a 1.6 but audi recommend all fsi engines to run on super unleaded so they know what they are doing :) it says so inside the fuel filler cap on mine to run it on 97 I'm not going to argue for more mpg lol
     
  8. Cruiser89

    Cruiser89 Advanced In Car Tech Site Sponsor

    1,484
    222
    63
    Sounds good... Think i may follow the same principle as you.
     
  9. FranA3

    FranA3 FMDETAILING Regional Rep Site Sponsor Gold Supporter Audi A3 Team Brill Red

    7,236
    331
    83
    its like i said in an earlier post i only use tesco99 over shell because its 9p cheaper and the shell garage is way out of my way like the other way from where i live so its my chosen fuel
     
  10. leeroywarner

    leeroywarner Member

    52
    1
    8
    Little while back fifth gear did a test on fuels, videos still on YouTube. Proven torque and bhp increases through the rev range on performance cars. No improvement in run of the mill 1.3 fiesta.
    Best fuel was tescos super (or whatever the call it) better than ultima/optima etc
     
  11. FranA3

    FranA3 FMDETAILING Regional Rep Site Sponsor Gold Supporter Audi A3 Team Brill Red

    7,236
    331
    83
    its tesco momentum99 mate
     
  12. marknjayne

    marknjayne Member

    425
    16
    18
    used bt ultimate once in an old skyline and hit quite high knock (between 70-80 on WOT) ,tesco 99 is my preferred choice as my clubcard likes it and its decent fuel,i think bp is 97 octane too whereas tesco and v-power are both 99
     
  13. RobinA3

    RobinA3 Well-Known Member

    1,827
    47
    48
    Tesco 99 for the R32 - the missus does thw weekly shop there.

    Shell V-Power for the Polo and the S2000 as its rated at 99ron when it comes out the pump.
     
  14. marknjayne

    marknjayne Member

    425
    16
    18
    the thing is a 1.3 fiesta has a simple ecu and wont react to fuel like a car such as an S3 etc will,in fact there was a test with an impreza (think it was evo mag) and the results were surprising,think there was about a 20 hp difference
     
  15. benppl

    benppl Member

    54
    1
    6
    Normal stuff for me, I've read mixed reviews about the 'high octane' fuels and have decided its not worth the cash ( IMO of course )
     
  16. S3Alex

    S3Alex Rarely neutral Team Ibis TFSI Owners Group Gold Supporter Audi S3 DSG

    10,758
    4,780
    113
    For a modified car,running high levels of boost,it's essential to use as high an octane fuel as possible,i.e 99RON if available,to avoid timing pull at high boost and intake temperatures.

    I don't think in overall terms it makes a lot of difference using V-Power,Ultimate,or Momentum,as long as you use something in that range.

    If the car and settings are stock,it won't make a huge difference.
     
  17. flying oyster

    flying oyster flying oyster

    563
    27
    28
    i use v max when i can and when i run back to wales once a month my mpg is always better on the vmax than other fuel
     
  18. FranA3

    FranA3 FMDETAILING Regional Rep Site Sponsor Gold Supporter Audi A3 Team Brill Red

    7,236
    331
    83
    on my car i need as much extra HP otherwise its so slow lol
     
  19. kirsty76

    kirsty76 Member

    255
    2
    18
    yea tesco buy there fuel from esso as they dont have their own refinerys, but tesco add there own addatives to the fuel so the normal stuff is not as good as buying it from esso.
     
  20. Helifella

    Helifella Co-Driver ~ Hattie Staff Member Moderator Regional Rep VCDS Map User

    569
    149
    43
    1st choice Shell V power, 2nd BP Ultimate and if i'm caught short the nearest bush for a quick squirt then a top up at prev choices.

    I heard that the higher the performance engine the more noticable gains can be had.
     
  21. cloughy

    cloughy Member

    515
    18
    18
    Petrol using premium fuel (tesco 99) does make it run better

    Diesel using premium fuel can't see a difference

    From the research I did a while ago, all the fuel comes from the same refinery except for premium fuel like ultimate

    the brands like esso and shell will put additives into the tanker on regular fuel on collection

    Where as someone like asda will not. That's my 2 pence.
     
  22. paddy

    paddy Audi=No fault code, no idea Team Ibis Audi S3 Black Edition DSG

    5,230
    153
    63
    Some of you will remember the write up I did on this a few years back with Tesco std and Tesco 99 + 4 runs on the RR over the month.
    Tesco 99 gave exactly 10 bhp more on my mapped 3.2. Not noticeable when driving, about 2.5% increase.
    Its the most extra power you can get out of a 3.2 this side of a few £grand .
    I have always been an advocate of Tesco 99 and a few years ago i was shouted down by most here for saying it was as good as V.Power. :) How times have changed now people area a little hard up :)
    Only time any fuel really made a difference that you would notice on the road was a tank of BP Ultimate that was like un-mapping the S3 for 300 Miles.!!!! Must have just been a bad tank full but never again !!
     
  23. MattBE

    MattBE Member

    58
    2
    6
    Interesting that BP have dropped their '102 Ultimate' unleaded now citing that they didn't sell very much of it. Or could it be that at £2.40 a litre its not actually that expensive now!!

    My two cents is v-power or Tesco 99 in petrol cars. My 350z hated BP ultimate for some reason!! I'm a real believer in the cleaning qualities of V-Power and that premium fuels just seem to make a car 'feel' better. I'm sure its a placebo effect but considering i'm now paying upwards of £70 to fill my car up, £2.40 on top makes very little difference to me.
     
  24. S3Alex

    S3Alex Rarely neutral Team Ibis TFSI Owners Group Gold Supporter Audi S3 DSG

    10,758
    4,780
    113
    Time for the water/meth kit Paddy!
     
  25. essIII

    essIII Active Member

    285
    35
    28
    Tesco 99 in my S3, or VPower if I get caught short on the motorway.
     
  26. willowsdad

    willowsdad Sideways

    1,027
    32
    48
    I filled my 3.2 up with normal bp unleaded ( accidentally ) when i first got it, and it ran horribly with a noticable lack of power. Now its always tesco 99, runs a hundred times smoother. Not sure about an increase in mpg though, the missus has got a heavy right boot!
     
  27. Brodster

    Brodster Well-Known Member Team Ibis VCDS Map User Audi S4 Audi Avant Owner Group

    3,548
    885
    113
    I use Sainsburys 98RON Super-unleaded and at 128.7p/litre cannot grumble. Ive tried a few tanks worth of BP and seems to be roughly the same performance and MPG. I dont know if its a main stream supplier of Sainsburys fuel but seems OK to me.

    Brodster
     
  28. S3Alex

    S3Alex Rarely neutral Team Ibis TFSI Owners Group Gold Supporter Audi S3 DSG

    10,758
    4,780
    113
    .
     
    Last edited: Dec 8, 2011
  29. S3RYE

    S3RYE Interior Next!!

    3,448
    70
    36
    V-POWER adl.. :thumbsup: i have three of them in close proximity.
     
  30. N8

    N8 Kowalski Details VCDS Map User

    17,163
    718
    113
    SHELL ADL, V-Power Locator App on the iPhone :wub:
     
  31. MartayMcFly

    MartayMcFly Booooooost VCDS Map User Gold Supporter

    2,760
    354
    83
    Always used V-Power in both S3s, apart from once or twice when I couldn't get to a Shell station I'd use Tesco99 but only enough to get to a Shell station.
     
  32. BlueSpark

    BlueSpark 6th Gear

    386
    6
    18
    Have to be honest only ever used Shell V-power in mine as i have V-power membership card and get money off fuel by accumulating points via vouchers.

    V-power does make a difference as throttle response is improved, acceleration and MPG if driven sensibly.

    I tend to only use shell, BP fuels with past cars as i find the supermarket fuels dont feel as responsive.
     
  33. S3 Rav

    S3 Rav Well-Known Member

    2,825
    30
    48
    I use v power. Have used Bp ultimate on two occasions and both times felt the s3 was alot slower. Not again.
     
  34. paddy

    paddy Audi=No fault code, no idea Team Ibis Audi S3 Black Edition DSG

    5,230
    153
    63
    I got one of them cards....I bought a 1000ltrs and got a £5 voucher....Thats half a pee a ltr back..And the fuel is 6p a ltr more expensive than Tesco 99.
    Work it out :) It cost £3 more to fill the tank and they give you 25p back for loyalty..........lol
     
  35. Minstadave

    Minstadave Member

    560
    19
    18
    Sainsbury's super is 97 isn't it?
     
  36. legin

    legin Member

    76
    1
    6
    Ok. I work very closely with this and know much of what goes into all the fuel from major retailers in the uk and can tell you the following. V power is the best fuel you can buy as its 99 ron and has enhanced additives, tesco would be the very next best imo especially if its cheaper. BP is poor old stuff due to lower octane and the experience comments are pretty near to the reality. You will get more go out of your turbo nutter petrol with a premium fuel its a fact, again I know this from test data. Forget the diesel equivalents.

    No placebo my friend and you should be a fuel tester.

    "My two cents is v-power or Tesco 99 in petrol cars. My 350z hated BP ultimate for some reason!! I'm a real believer in the cleaning qualities of V-Power and that premium fuels just seem to make a car 'feel' better. I'm sure its a placebo effect but considering i'm now paying upwards of £70 to fill my car up, £2.40 on top makes very little difference to me."
     
  37. cloughy

    cloughy Member

    515
    18
    18
    Legin, no benefit to premium diesel then mate?
     
  38. DJ-S3

    DJ-S3 Active Member

    690
    43
    28
    I use Sainsburys super unleaded, would love to be able to use Tesco's but the closest one to me is 8miles away!!! :(
     
  39. TimJK

    TimJK Member

    429
    7
    18
    My Leon cupra r was mapped to v power so swore by it.

    I put tesco 99 or vpower in the s3 though.

    Bp is only 97 so wouldn't touch it.

    Clive Atthowe who does revo etc in Norwich said he has proven shell is the best in scoobies which he also tunes and usually run 15bhp more.
     
  40. legin

    legin Member

    76
    1
    6
    It is a very small benefit if at all and certainly not worth paying extra so yes I would avoid
     

Share This Page