1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Audi S3 or Audi A3 3.2 Quattro

DJ-S3 Oct 22, 2010

  1. DJ-S3

    DJ-S3 Active Member

    690
    43
    28
    Hi there,
    I sold my S3 nearly a year ago and am regretting it massively. As the title says im thinking about either one of them two cars, which one do you lot think i should go for?

    A3 good points:
    DSG
    Exhaust note
    Price/age

    S3 good points:
    Looks better
    Better MPG (am i right in thinking this?)
    With a remap would be faster

    A3 bad points:
    Fuel consumption
    Doesn't look as good
    Any more?

    S3 bad points:
    Rust from past experiance
    Age/price (there older with alot more mileage)
    Already had one (not sure this is actually a bad thing ha)
    Doesn't sound as good as the 3.2
    Any more?

    I've got about £9000 max to spend on the car, lower the better.

    Cheers in advance

    Dom
     
  2. Sarah's A3

    Sarah's A3 MODERATOR V6 S3 Hybrid Moderator

    5,920
    30
    38
    Well Dom, I am going to say 3.2, but I would wouldnt I lol! Yes the S3 can be remapped and tuned but this can lead to other issues and reliability problems. The fuel consumption wont be too far apart from the 2 cars. Insurance costs mey be less on the 3.2. The sound of the 3.2 is awsome unlike the S3 lol!
    Oh and if you want the 3.2 to be quicker, just bolt a turbo on and an intercooler and hey, bingo!!!

    Good luck choosing and sure you will get some conflicting thoughts as there are alot of S3 owners on here. The S3 is a good car and you can tune it far better but tbh the 3.2 is just brilliant! (to me anyway!)
     
    Last edited: Oct 22, 2010
  3. Ash B

    Ash B Well-Known Member

    5,831
    85
    48
    Hi Dom

    I'd probably go for the 3.2 V6 S-line. Its newer, better looking ish i suppose (im not too sure:think:) and sounds alot better than an 8L S3.
    But i suppose its down to your own taste really. Why not test drive an 3.2 and see how you get on? As you already know how an 8L S3 feels after you already owning one.
    As said with the 3.2 tuning wise supercharger or turbo both big money (but big gains) in less you can speak to some the yanks about the kits they have on their R32s and A3 3.2 over there. What was the reason for selling the S3? But to be fair the 8L S3 does still look good for its age and doesnt look dated at all next to newer vehicle and are alot more tuneable. Every time i see an 8L S3 i think how beautiful they look. Test drive both and go from there
    Cheers


    EDIT: Think the 8L S3 looks better than the 3.2 that is Standard, Sport or pre facelift split grill.
    But if S-line id say the 3.2
     
    Last edited: Oct 22, 2010
  4. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    130
    38
    Sarah, what ARE you saying? S3? Reliability issues? I simply won't have that.....

    :lmfao:
     
  5. Ash B

    Ash B Well-Known Member

    5,831
    85
    48
    Think the insurance wouldnt be an issue both group 18 if im right?
    Regarding tuning and reliability problems that will happen on any car you tune.
    Just depends if you do everything right etc

    Good luck with the search anyway Dom. Sure you will pick the one you want most
     
    Last edited: Oct 22, 2010
  6. -Ju-

    -Ju- Well-Known Member VCDS Map User Team Panther Audi S3

    2,417
    516
    113
    I'd definitely go for the 3.2. It's on the later platform, has a much nicer interior, sounds better and has the option of dsg.
    Mpg wise I would say there isn't much in it. I traded a 225 remapped LCR in for my first 3.2 and the consumption was almost identical.
    As for looks, then you need to go for the right A3, as in standard sport form it can be quite bland and look like any other A3.
    Your not too far from me so your welcome to come for a spin in mine if you like
     
  7. s3dave

    s3dave TFSI Hybrid Supporter

    10,110
    736
    38
     
  8. mk1chopper

    mk1chopper Missing the S3

    1,092
    12
    36
    Go and drive one and see what you think. I've never driven the 3.2 but I've heard its pretty dull in the handling department (not that the S3 is the most engaging drive either), my brother test drove a few and wasnt that impressed by them. That fact its a newer car would be the big appeal for me. The dash and interior is nicer but the seats are lame compared to the recaros in the S3. Insurance wise they should be similar S3 is either group 17 or 18 dependant on 210/225 engine. Personally I'd look at a mk4 R32 or an E46 M3.
     
  9. Sarah's A3

    Sarah's A3 MODERATOR V6 S3 Hybrid Moderator

    5,920
    30
    38
     
  10. Ash B

    Ash B Well-Known Member

    5,831
    85
    48
    Why would you look at a MK4 R32 with the same engine? Ok the R32 got alot more hype than the 3.2 v6 but more or less the same cars just different badges etc.
     
  11. Sarah's A3

    Sarah's A3 MODERATOR V6 S3 Hybrid Moderator

    5,920
    30
    38
    I agree the S Line looks lovely but once kitted up just has a llittle something special. Although an 8L has a good look too.....oh decisions decisions lol

    Good luck choosing mate
     
    Last edited: Oct 22, 2010
  12. mk1chopper

    mk1chopper Missing the S3

    1,092
    12
    36
    For 9k a B6 S4 Avant can be had, better equiped than either the A3 or the S3, proper 4 wheel drive faster than both and the V8 sounds better.

    Audi : Audi S4

    Note: Im ignoring running costs here
     
  13. mk1chopper

    mk1chopper Missing the S3

    1,092
    12
    36
    Better seats, different suspension setup, rarer
     
  14. Sean_S3

    Sean_S3 Member

    323
    17
    18
    If you have £9K to spend your going to get a great example whichever car you go for so I would say drive both and see which one you like the most now. I personally think the 3.2 doesn't look as distinctive as it should considering the engine size and power but this could be said for most 8P models. The wide arches and a nice set of 18" wheels make the 8L S3 and like others have said its still a great looking car for its age.
     
  15. s3dave

    s3dave TFSI Hybrid Supporter

    10,110
    736
    38
    Arnt the 3.2,s very nose heavy in the twisties??......:undwech:
     
  16. finesse

    finesse Active Member

    2,805
    11
    38
    thought about it too, 8P S3's at 75k miles + are going for £17k
     
  17. Ash B

    Ash B Well-Known Member

    5,831
    85
    48
    Yours is a perfect example aswell with the full S3 kit!

    Probably just have to agree to disagree lol. I dont like the MK4 R32 Seats...I like the MK5 bucket seats they go quite cheap with higher miles than average on autotrader. But wouldnt say Mk4 R32 were rarer mind.



    Hmm S4 sound lovely and beautiful! If i could get insured on an S4 i'd have one.
     
  18. Ash B

    Ash B Well-Known Member

    5,831
    85
    48
    Miles on such a new car for me are offer putting. I'm just waiting till later next year when 56-57reg have lowered.



    Haha yeah Dave thats true i believe, but probably only noticeable on a track
     
    Last edited: Oct 22, 2010
  19. Sean_S3

    Sean_S3 Member

    323
    17
    18
    There's an 07 Grey 8P S3 for sale not far from me , 27,000 miles on the clock and only £16,990. Very tempted to go inquire....
     
  20. Sarah's A3

    Sarah's A3 MODERATOR V6 S3 Hybrid Moderator

    5,920
    30
    38
    Nah! it still goes round nice and fast and no slide lol! Or is that just mine lol
     
  21. s3dave

    s3dave TFSI Hybrid Supporter

    10,110
    736
    38
    Only because you are used to front heavy things......lol...:undwech:
     
  22. Ash B

    Ash B Well-Known Member

    5,831
    85
    48
    :laugh:
     
    Last edited: Oct 22, 2010
  23. Sarah's A3

    Sarah's A3 MODERATOR V6 S3 Hybrid Moderator

    5,920
    30
    38

    lol
     
  24. NHN

    NHN Retrofitter - Audi - VW - Skoda - Seat Site Sponsor VCDS Map User

    29,577
    1,779
    113
    S3 8L hands down, had 1 for 7 years & still miss it, 3.2 sounds good to most but not me, I dont go for sounds in cars, the S3 will give you smiles on your face far longer than the 3.2 will ever.
     
  25. voorhees

    voorhees Moderator Staff Member Moderator Team V8 Audi S5 s tronic

    16,249
    2,072
    113
  26. sportquattro

    sportquattro Active Member

    845
    51
    28
    S3, better looking, easier to tune, better economy, better handling at a guess, and probably hold value better. Agree 3.2 sounds great but think the S3 is the better package. But as other have said, drive both and go with whatever you, like best, youre the one tha'ts paying for and driving the thing, both great cars so don't think you will be disappointed either way.
     
  27. s3dave

    s3dave TFSI Hybrid Supporter

    10,110
    736
    38
    post the same question on the 8p section.....lol
     
  28. voorhees

    voorhees Moderator Staff Member Moderator Team V8 Audi S5 s tronic

    16,249
    2,072
    113
    yeah and ask whats better looking a mean stance 8L S3 or a boggo 8P A3 :)
     
  29. s3dave

    s3dave TFSI Hybrid Supporter

    10,110
    736
    38
    Exactly....
     
  30. jojo

    jojo Looking for Boost! Staff Member Moderator Team Daytona Audi S3 quattro Audi A6 Audi Avant Owner Group

    28,998
    3,652
    113
    £9k budget, buy a cheap S3 and drop a 3.2 V6 in it....
     
  31. Sarah's A3

    Sarah's A3 MODERATOR V6 S3 Hybrid Moderator

    5,920
    30
    38
    Oi! you, not all 3.2s are boggo!!!!
     
  32. MURRAYS444

    MURRAYS444 Member

    790
    38
    16
    I say S3 all the way mate the new shape A3s and S3s all look the same but if you have £9000 get an S3 8l facelift for about £6,500 and spend the rest on remapping and other tuning stuff!!!
     
  33. MURRAYS444

    MURRAYS444 Member

    790
    38
    16
    Oh and I just fitted a Jetex cone filter and it sound unbelievable:yum:
     
  34. luke2702

    luke2702 Member

    446
    0
    16
    S3 gets my vote too.
     
  35. voorhees

    voorhees Moderator Staff Member Moderator Team V8 Audi S5 s tronic

    16,249
    2,072
    113
    Oooops meant when you bought new :ninja:
     
  36. NoggyS3

    NoggyS3 Member

    242
    1
    16
    :s3addict: Dude

    As said with 9k to play with you could have a very nice S3 with plenty of change to make it your own :thumbsup:
     
  37. finesse

    finesse Active Member

    2,805
    11
    38
    one thing the 3.2 and S3 have in common is a slack chain tensioner
     
  38. Sarah's A3

    Sarah's A3 MODERATOR V6 S3 Hybrid Moderator

    5,920
    30
    38
    Better from Mr Stealth! lol
     
  39. 1animal1

    1animal1 The Clar!! it mouves!!! VCDS Map User

    9,978
    36
    48
    another here for 8L S3, you'll have change and a faster car without the urge to make it look like an S3 (no offence guys ;) )....my dilemma is that i can afford an 8P S3 but not a facelift version, i know for a fact that i will spend my life speccing the pre face to make it MY11 which in my mind is pointless

    dont get me wrong, i love the 8P as it feels so much more modern, if your anything like me though, you'll always want the top spec
     
  40. finesse

    finesse Active Member

    2,805
    11
    38
    whats this MY11 business?:unsure::unsure:
     

Share This Page