1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

1.8T 20V Con Rod Failures

Welly Oct 8, 2010

  1. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
  2. Dane

    Dane Had an 8L S3, a B5 RS4 now I have a B8 S4

    4,086
    182
    63
    After our chat the other evening this is my next job. :thumbsup:
     
  3. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
    A wise decision.... It just shows that in reality, it's not if. But when.
     
  4. Alex C

    Alex C Well-Known Member VCDS Map User Audi S3

    3,294
    372
    83
    have there been instances of rod failure on stage 1 maps or even just standard engines?
     
  5. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
  6. Alex C

    Alex C Well-Known Member VCDS Map User Audi S3

    3,294
    372
    83
    ah, yeah i remember you had that failure, didnt realise you were stage 1. Do you think its too conservative to have new rods beofre going stage 1?
     
  7. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
    I don't think it's conservative to have new rods at any time. IMO 1.8T rods are gash.
     
  8. S3 TAM

    S3 TAM Pocket now empty

    624
    10
    18
    Its on the massive list of things to do. Lol
     
  9. DaveA3

    DaveA3 Audi A-Trizzle!

    2,370
    15
    38
    ahh man! i hate reading stuff like this it makes me think theyre gonna go now everytime i drive my car :(
     
  10. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
    You should be OK dude to be fair, what the output on your A3? Bear in mind that the S3s have the same rods as you (presuming you're an AGUer) and run more power standard....
     
  11. jojo

    jojo Looking for Boost! Staff Member Moderator Team Daytona Audi S3 quattro Audi A6 Audi Avant Owner Group

    28,944
    3,598
    113
    You also have to put it on the choice of stage1 map also, all this 'low down grunt' with 'push in the back' torque is bad for the rods.
     
  12. DaveA3

    DaveA3 Audi A-Trizzle!

    2,370
    15
    38
    185bhp with boost leaks lol should be about 190bhp think it was something like 214 lb/ft torques need to double check that. yeh im on an AGU.

    cheers man thats good to hear :D
     
  13. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
    You should be A OK mate, I wouldn't lose sleep.
     
  14. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
    Agreed, finger pointing towards REVO maps here....lol.
     
  15. superkarl

    superkarl MAN OF STEEL

    9,571
    2,464
    113
    is a revo map a dangerous one then on standard internals?
     
  16. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
    No, not dangerous. However, REVO maps are known for their aggressive delivery by all. Much less progressive than other maps, and that's due to the torque production. As Jo said, early and harsh torque isn't the best for the rods.

    Many people are using, and have used, REVO maps for a long time with no issues. But out of the generic maps available, I would say they are the most likely to cause issues. That's not to say will.
     
  17. superkarl

    superkarl MAN OF STEEL

    9,571
    2,464
    113
    i see what you mean. id want a more progressive map anyway. my car is off the road soon and after the wear and tear stuff i've got to do, rods are my number 1 before i get a map. better safe than sorry
     
  18. S3 Nattie

    S3 Nattie Quattro ist für sissies

    1,599
    8
    36
    People need to stop thinking there engines are going to fall apart any minute lol. Ye rods fall but its a very small minority that do and they tend to be running quite a bit more torque and power than the standard engine spec.

    Im doing a con rod FEA assignment in uni now and wanted to do it on a S3 rod but havent got the dimensions on one to measure accurately.

    Nathan
     
  19. Alex C

    Alex C Well-Known Member VCDS Map User Audi S3

    3,294
    372
    83
    well perhaps if i change my rods because im too scared to go without doing it you could have my OEM rod to do your FEM :moa:
     
  20. S3 Nattie

    S3 Nattie Quattro ist für sissies

    1,599
    8
    36
    Lol thats sounds like a good idea to me.

    Nathan
     
  21. tompearson

    tompearson It's all in bits

    219
    1
    16
    I have some in my garage - what measurements do you want? (or are you meaning you want to test to destruction?)

    Also have some IE and Brute ones if you need a comparison.
     
  22. S3 Nattie

    S3 Nattie Quattro ist für sissies

    1,599
    8
    36
    I would need the following;

    Length from top to bottom
    Width of the rod
    Diameter of the gudgeon pin and bearing but I think I have just found them on the net.
    Distance from the gudgeon pin to the outer side of the rod.
    The radius of the rod stem where it meets the gudgeon pin and the bear
    Diameter of the stem just after the radius's top and bottom
    The radius's, diameters and lengths of the intersect in the rod and how far into the rod it is to get a section view of the rod.
    Would also need the measurement around the bearing but unsure how to describe them.

    Its pretty easy to measure the rod but its then working out what happening within the engine such as cylinder pressure at certain rpm's, air/fuel mass within the cylinders, the acceleration and resistant forces acting on the rod, tension and compression forces, vertical and horizontal force acting on the rod and bending monents/loads etc to get a full understanding of what the rod if being exerted too.

    Im actually doing my final year project on My S3 and might start a thread as it should contain very useful info.

    Does anyone know what the factor of safety is on a S3 rod.

    If I had one I would measure one up myself. I might be able to get one in the from a vag garage I know by me. Mainly have jags and Ford rods in uni.

    Nathan
     
    Last edited: Oct 8, 2010
  23. finesse

    finesse Active Member

    2,805
    11
    38
    Nathan, what package are you using for analysis? Ansys, Abacus, Catia, Solidworks?

    I would guess a safety factor of 1.5
     
  24. S3 Nattie

    S3 Nattie Quattro ist für sissies

    1,599
    8
    36
    We have got solidworks but I dont use it, heard its quite user friendly. Were using NX now and I think NX7 is being installed over the weekend, think thats the latest NX verison you can get. NX is very good but like most software, it likes to freeze and run very slowly sometimes.

    Nathan
     
  25. Essflee

    Essflee Well-Known Member

    2,152
    67
    48
    If I listened to every horror story I'd heard about S3's etc, I'd never have got a remap and would of sold it a long time ago... Lol
     
  26. superkarl

    superkarl MAN OF STEEL

    9,571
    2,464
    113
    well you hear the horror stories, and then the cost and pain in the ass of sorting it out. so if you can prevent it, you may aswell. i know i dont want to be buyin new engines. especially when your car has done as many miles as mine. Im over modding for power, i want to increase the longetivity of my car now, because i dont wana sell, so il keep till it proper dies. Rods just come into the equation when prolonging the life of it. its just a bonus that i won't ever need to worry about bending one. unless one day i have a spike of 500lbsft of torque or somethin crazy like that, which will never happen.
     
  27. S3 Nattie

    S3 Nattie Quattro ist für sissies

    1,599
    8
    36
    Lol Im with you there. Everyone on this forum will try there best to give everyone else the best advise as possible and 99% of the time its very good advise. But theres got to come a point where you say its not realistic or cost efficient to do so for YOUR situation.

    Nathan
     
  28. finesse

    finesse Active Member

    2,805
    11
    38
    NX makes me sick, but it is powerful.

    I have a conrod I modelled here if you want......
     
  29. S3 Nattie

    S3 Nattie Quattro ist für sissies

    1,599
    8
    36
    Lol ye NX is very powerful software and it nearly literally made me sick last year when I was doing some work and it decided it wanted to just randomly freeze and shut off and I never saved any of my work. Good job I have a very understand lecturer.

    You have got a actually working model of a S3 con rod. That would be interesting to have a look at.

    Nathan
     
  30. finesse

    finesse Active Member

    2,805
    11
    38
    Not S3, just a generic one I used for analysis and mold and manufacturing in NX

    NX:Flush::Flush:
     
  31. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
    Look, bottom line, I thought it was useful info for people.

    It doesn't happen to everyone, but it DID happen to me.

    If I can help people avoid the drama and cost that I went through, then I will bloody well try! lol.
     
  32. finesse

    finesse Active Member

    2,805
    11
    38
    Totally agree, it is a job which should be on every enthusiasts list.

    It's not appealing because it doesn't provide epic 5bhp gain like an air filter or stop better like 8 pot brakes
     
  33. Alex C

    Alex C Well-Known Member VCDS Map User Audi S3

    3,294
    372
    83
    how much would you be looking at paying for the rods and fitting?
     
  34. s3dave

    s3dave TFSI Hybrid Supporter

    10,110
    736
    38
    I dont think you will have a lot of change out of a grand with new shells, oil, belt ,gaskets etc.

    I agree with welly, he is not scaremongering, just giving good info that may or may-not be heeded, depending on your application......
     
    Last edited: Oct 8, 2010
  35. finesse

    finesse Active Member

    2,805
    11
    38
  36. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
  37. Alex C

    Alex C Well-Known Member VCDS Map User Audi S3

    3,294
    372
    83
    thanks guys, im not gonna rush out and do it, but food for thought, cheers Welly!
     
  38. S3 Nattie

    S3 Nattie Quattro ist für sissies

    1,599
    8
    36
    I agree with you, thats what forums are for, giving members advise to benefit them or fill them in with info.

    Just wondering, what are the torques for the shell.

    Nathan
     
  39. drfeelgood

    drfeelgood Member

    225
    1
    16
    This is the reason why i wont do anything to the engine.
     
  40. Welly

    Welly VX220 SC Driver :)

    10,696
    129
    38
    lol, and who could blame you dude. Tits and wheels are nothing but trouble.
     

Share This Page