My s3 is dead

Driver or mechanical error?


  • Total voters
    48
I suspect that we won't be seeing StephenHirst here any more, since he's binned the S3 and bought a 330 M-Sport instead.

To update on his behalf though, Stephen got in touch with me and we discussed the issue and circumstances for a brief period. I then drafted a letter for him to send to Audi UK challenging the lack of any proper root cause analysis and asking for clarification on how they can refuse a claim based upon ECU data points that lack credibility.

Audi replied to Stephen 4 days later. While they didn't offer any explanations on why or how the data points can be recorded, they did offer to pick up almost half of the £5.5k bill for the repair, an offer he accepted.

Just goes to show, you should never-ever take the dealers word for it, and even when all appears lost, it never-ever hurts to ask.
That's a fair result in the end and I'm sure he'll buy you a few beers for your efforts.

That's what I like about this forum, there are people willing to come forward and help others in their time of need.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rob2k68, richinsoton, pastey and 5 others
This is so sad, at least this has come to an end now for you, thanks for the update.

So you had the car repaired and then moved on?
yeh its sad to see it go, i drove it again for the first time in 6 months and it was like driving it for the first time all over again, had me so happy for that last hour, but i now have a new car which is insane in so many different ways then the s3.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rob2k68
yeh its sad to see it go, i drove it again for the first time in 6 months and it was like driving it for the first time all over again, had me so happy for that last hour, but i now have a new car which is insane in so many different ways then the s3.

It's such a shame and sad to hear, poor car.

I'm glad you are happy now at least and all is resolved.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rob2k68 and davc
I suspect that we won't be seeing StephenHirst here any more, since he's binned the S3 and bought a 330 M-Sport instead.

To update on his behalf though, Stephen got in touch with me and we discussed the issue and circumstances for a brief period. I then drafted a letter for him to send to Audi UK challenging the lack of any proper root cause analysis and asking for clarification on how they can refuse a claim based upon ECU data points that lack credibility.

Audi replied to Stephen 4 days later. While they didn't offer any explanations on why or how the data points can be recorded, they did offer to pick up almost half of the £5.5k bill for the repair, an offer he accepted.

Just goes to show, you should never-ever take the dealers word for it, and even when all appears lost, it never-ever hurts to ask.
That's a really kind thing to do Grant, well done.













Still think his brother blew his car up though :tonguewink:
 
  • Like
Reactions: zippster, jungle650, OliS3 and 8 others
yeh its sad to see it go, i drove it again for the first time in 6 months and it was like driving it for the first time all over again, had me so happy for that last hour, but i now have a new car which is insane in so many different ways then the s3.
What have you replaced it with an M or AMG car by any chance?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rob2k68
I suspect that we won't be seeing StephenHirst here any more, since he's binned the S3 and bought a 330 M-Sport instead.

To update on his behalf though, Stephen got in touch with me and we discussed the issue and circumstances for a brief period. I then drafted a letter for him to send to Audi UK challenging the lack of any proper root cause analysis and asking for clarification on how they can refuse a claim based upon ECU data points that lack credibility.

Audi replied to Stephen 4 days later. While they didn't offer any explanations on why or how the data points can be recorded, they did offer to pick up almost half of the £5.5k bill for the repair, an offer he accepted.

Just goes to show, you should never-ever take the dealers word for it, and even when all appears lost, it never-ever hurts to ask.

Good work Grant excellent result !!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: zippster
That's a really kind thing to do Grant, well done.

Still think his brother blew his car up though :tonguewink:

As @batch stated, thats a very nice thing for you to have done @GSB Thats what this forum is all about.

Nice one
Jungle
 
  • Like
Reactions: zippster

Similar threads

Replies
60
Views
13K
Replies
140
Views
8K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
120
Views
54K