Bad battery, or alternator?

J Eyo

Polo GTI (6) R
Joined
Dec 10, 2013
Messages
220
Reaction score
18
Points
18
Location
Melbourne
Hi guys,

so running my s3 with a deka battery, all good for quite a while (few months) then boom, n75H stops working and bad idle (missing, lumpy like a have a boost leak) and max pressure exceeded code. Being an n75H I think its the valve itself that's kicked the bucket. When i had a smoke pressure test done I had the actuator, n75H and forge DV tested separately and all is a-ok, however the n75h was throwing a max pressure exceeded code literally the moment it was plugged in.

So, again thought the H was dead, located an original, stuck it in, if i SLOWLY accelerate it boosts to 4000rpm ish, then does this very strange thing where it keeps activating on and off 4-5times gives really staggered boost, hits about 4-4500 and gone, throws max pressure code and I'm stuck in limp. At WOT there's nothing, nothing, nothing, turbo is spooling like a mofo, then suddenly boom, hard boost, then clunk gone and code.

Idle has been pretty awful the last 2 months (like I have a boost leak, disconnecting MAF makes no difference) since the n75 started playing up (and was the reason for the smoke test)

Also, there has been an actuator sound (a very quick pfft) before the blow off sound (new development, only since these problems began) so the n75's have been sending some strange signals. Actuator has NO play and the bolts are 100% a-ok.

About 3 weeks ago, when i was putting my windows up, it effected my idle, making it quite noticeably swing, so gave it a few consecutive pulls on the window switches and sure enough I can make my idle swing pretty drastically, if i flick the window switches up over and over like a mad mad I can almost get the engine to the point of stalling.

Which brings me to my new idea, bad battery? or bad alternator? Battery was the recommended deka, was fine for a few months and now dying (11.4V with engine off), because of a bad alternator? Could a bad alternator have been the cause of my slightly swinging idle (and at times pretty inconsistent turbo) since day one? (buying the car stock a year ago)

Climate control logged my voltage (20C) and with the engine off the battery is giving me 11.4 which seems very low. At idle it fluctuates between 12.9 and 14 at a pinch, whilst driving it fluctuates wildly between about 13.2 and 14.

And as always, help!!
 
I would say battery, you can try connecting a second battery with jump leads while the car is running , to see if the idle improves, as for the n75 I would say it's knackered, I had the same problem in my old A3, I Baught a new n75 and all was well again.
 
If the N75 has been acting up since plugging in, might be a dud, but I'm thinking it might be a wiring issue. I suggest checking the N75 and coilpack wiring for cracked insulation, especially since other electrical power (windows) is affecting your idle...
 
May need to look into that, straaaaange thing, last night went to start the car, all the dash lights flickered like crazy before it turned on, really static flashing for about 2-3 seconds, then the headlights did the something, very static fast flickering. The Deka battery is brand new, but there have been idle issues since day one, i'll looking into a new coil pack and n75 wiring kit, part numbers by any chance?
 
with the car running at idle, and the lights on and wipers, what reading do you get at the battery with a multi meter? a fluctuating voltage to me would suggest a faulty alternator, but dont hold me on that (im just a mechanic lol) not supplying enough current back to the battery, ideally you want anything at or over 14 volts back at the battery whilst underload (engine on and lights and wipers ect) this would show the alternator is dealing with the extra ask of power. and also a check of the battery reading with a multimeter last thing at night, then first thing in the morning to see if the battery has lost significant charge would also help.
 
May need to look into that, straaaaange thing, last night went to start the car, all the dash lights flickered like crazy before it turned on, really static flashing for about 2-3 seconds, then the headlights did the something, very static fast flickering.

this sounds more like a bad connection/earth, or very remote possibility that a diode is shorting in the alternator.

there are a bunch of earths under the battery and some bolted fuse connections on top of it, check those
also the big fuse is more like a metal plate, these have been known to get hairline fractures and the become intermittant
 
Sounds like you've got 2 seperate problems, i'd agree with newbster on a bad earth, could be as simple as a poor connection on the battery

Looking at your other threads you've been having problems with your boost for a while, get rid of the N75H valve. It's hot under an S3's bonnet and Ohm resistance will increase the hotter it gets so more chance of overboost and a limpmode.

058-906-283-C 20-30 Ohm
058-906-283-F 25-35 Ohm
034-906-283-H 25-45 Ohm
034-906-283-J 20-40 Ohm
034-906-283-K 20-40 Ohm
 

Similar threads

Replies
15
Views
947
DCH
I
Replies
6
Views
978
imported_blackcat
I
Replies
0
Views
744