I have the same wing mirrors on mine and sometimes think they look the dogs and other times I'm not so sure.
The problem with the polished chrome mirrors, in my mind, is that they are for the previous generation of A3.
All the current S line models (s4, rs4, rs6 etc) use the brushed mirrors. The new S3 wont have chromed mirrors.
I also think those pictures don;t do the mirrors justice.
J.