i have a atmospheric dump valve, on my A3 1.8T '98, my car has no noticeable lack of power and i dont have to wait for the turbo presure to respool.
no fault codes, no fuel consumption increase no problem,
however i do have a satisfiing ptschhhhhhhh
it is no slower than any other astandard a3 turbo. dont be negative try it for yourself, mine is a bailey dv 26 and fits in the cold side of the intercooler pipe, anything that goes in place of the recirc valve will cause you problems if it is of the atmospheric style.
read the thread
hold the front page on dump valves!!!!