I have to own up for the 'OK' option. But that isnt taking any praise away from the S3. (in case anyone is puzzled by my rather tame response, I have an 8P S3)
I have to agree with other people describing the S3 as 'clinical' - maybe too clinical at times. It's fairly practical (in sportback guise), fairly quick (even in standard form), fairly economical with subtle sporty styling and reliable. IMO, the S3 does a lot of things very competently and ticks most boxes BUT I wouldnt say it excelled in any department. So one could argue it's kind of a 'jack of all trades'.
True,
There are cheaper cars than the S3
There are faster cars available than the S3
There are engines and exhausts that sound better than the S3 (V6, V8 etc...)
There are more economical cars than the S3 (diesel)
There are more practical cars than the S3
There are more involving cars to drive than the S3 (personal preferences)
and the list goes on & on & on....
BUT the S3 still does all those things more than adequately. For me, its a clinical all rounder - hence my 'OK' vote.
Currently me and the gf have S3, TT-s convertible and mini cooper.
Although it's the slowest, I love the crashy go-kart feel from the mini but I couldnt drive it all day long - hence my S3 ownership.
Exhaust note on the TT-s is 'raspier' and more distinct than the S3. I've noticed its design and style turns more heads than my S3. But it aint as practical as the S3
IMO, we all have different requirements, tastes and views about S3 ownership.
Hopefully this sounds balanced and unbiased towards the S3 without seemingly slating S3 ownership!!