Reinforce XS Manifold Welds

B

Barks

Registered User
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
336
Reaction score
1
Points
18
Location
Cheltenham
Hello,

Is there anyone around the Gloucestershire area who is able to reinforce the XS V2 K04 manifold welds, the Franken Manifold has to go!!

I am not after a freebie, just good welding.

Thanks

Barks
 
Barks said:
Hello,

Is there anyone around the Gloucestershire area who is able to reinforce the XS V2 K04 manifold welds, the Franken Manifold has to go!!

I am not after a freebie, just good welding.

Thanks

Barks
Click to expand...

Speak to s3 Dave. He isn't local, but Prawn + Westy have gone to him, might be others as well, and he has a same day it comes in its back out turn around, all for a good price for what he does.
 
Reesy said:
Speak to s3 Dave. He isn't local, but Prawn + Westy have gone to him, might be others as well, and he has a same day it comes in its back out turn around, all for a good price for what he does.
Click to expand...

Ah Yes, I had my rear Tie bars from Mr S3 Dave, Thanks
 
hello................

you do know where I am Dave..

like this> nickle rod used
IMAG1978.jpg


dont you?
eh?
 
I do, I do Bill, I haven't been on the forum for a while and didn't think it was a service you offered!! :)
 
I'm thinking of buying a relentless manifold, how come you have to re-weld them? Are they THAT bad?
 
Bill.....why is nickel rod used??? I'm a TIG welder by trade and curious???? thinking of investing in one of these myself, do they all need reinforcing or is it pretty obvious when you open the box??

Cheers, Chris
 
S321BAM said:
Bill.....why is nickel rod used??? I'm a TIG welder by trade and curious???? thinking of investing in one of these myself, do they all need reinforcing or is it pretty obvious when you open the box??

Cheers, Chris
Click to expand...

I should say hi-nickle content stainless rod to be precise. Used for dissimilar materials and supposed to be more crack resistant as a consequence.

Relentless dont backpurge their thin wall material welds.. and the most common area of failure is around the collector, as it gets the hottest. (like yellow hot!)

The "hope" is the additional welding around their welds (I back purge when going over them also) is to get thicker weld on the joins and to try and get full penetration weld in that area.

I say "hope" as its welding on top of their welding.. and quite what *actual* material it is is unknown.. I know what they claim it to be but I am a sceptical ******, hence using the stainless/nickle rods for dissimilars on them. I use the same rods for welding stainless/ferrous to cast components also... 100% reliable so far.

The V3 relentless is supposed to be better, but I have'nt seen one, and heard they still have'nt backpurged their welds despite changing material to a titanium induced 321 stainless.. (which sounds great as a sales pitch, but full properties will never be achieved unless full solution annealed to normalise welds........ which they dont do, not likely ever to)
 
looking at the original welds on the photo, looks like they don't use filler wire at all and just 'fuse' the joints together hense why they would crack. By saying back purge do you mean filling the inside of the manifold with argon??
 
S321BAM said:
looking at the original welds on the photo, looks like they don't use filler wire at all and just 'fuse' the joints together hense why they would crack. By saying back purge do you mean filling the inside of the manifold with argon??
Click to expand...

yes backpurge=argon inside tube..
they do "just" fuse the welds in most joints, without penetrating the thin 1.2mm wall thickness.. SO... @ welds its very thin without the full penetration, and if they did happen to break thru, the inside would coke up and oxidise without backpurge anyhow.

Fusion alone is'nt bad, so long as you make sure its 100% penetration and not an undercut sagged weld bead.

(I used to work for an engineering company as their Engineering Manager, and one of the products I did back in the 90's was autogenous welded 316L tube to make a coriolis mass flow meter, and this involved TIG fusion butt welded joints, no filler, and was 100% inspected to ensure full penetration etc etc.. All materials were post welding full solution annealed however also to ensure no heat effected zones as would otherwise occur. When I tensile tested the process whilst re-engineering the products production we had no loss of parent material mechanical properties... Just as good as if it had never been welded. Handy when the device when operating vibrated at 120Hz and would cycle >10.4million oscillations in a day... If there was a weakness it would crank in minutes/hours without the work we did to them)

I guess you dont do back purge welds on stainless where you work?
 
Last edited:
So basically save money and get the version 2 and then get you to weld it then Bill?
 
only had to purge weld a several times over the last 16 years, fabricated one off special purpose machinery were purge welding isn't really required. Remember a job years ago someone fused all the joints on a stainless water system, by the time it got to czech republic the majority of the welds had split, around 100m of pipe work!!
 
badger5 said:
I should say hi-nickle content stainless rod to be precise. Used for dissimilar materials and supposed to be more crack resistant as a consequence.

Relentless dont backpurge their thin wall material welds.. and the most common area of failure is around the collector, as it gets the hottest. (like yellow hot!)

The "hope" is the additional welding around their welds (I back purge when going over them also) is to get thicker weld on the joins and to try and get full penetration weld in that area.

I say "hope" as its welding on top of their welding.. and quite what *actual* material it is is unknown.. I know what they claim it to be but I am a sceptical ******, hence using the stainless/nickle rods for dissimilars on them. I use the same rods for welding stainless/ferrous to cast components also... 100% reliable so far.

The V3 relentless is supposed to be better, but I have'nt seen one, and heard they still have'nt backpurged their welds despite changing material to a titanium induced 321 stainless.. (which sounds great as a sales pitch, but full properties will never be achieved unless full solution annealed to normalise welds........ which they dont do, not likely ever to)
Click to expand...

I've JUST ordered one from relentless in America, If i post it to you would you weld it up and send it me back? I'll cover all costs obviously.. And it'll give you chance to check out a brand new one :)

Ben
 
Cool mate, cheers. I'll give you a ring when it arrives :)

Ben
 
Hi Bill,

How much for the welding fella? Can you PM me please? Also can you fit the v2 if so would you recommend doing the rods and piston rings?
 
audi upgrades
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Jeepster
XS power exhaust manifold
Replies
11
Views
2K
Jimgrim77
J
W
Ko3 xs pro manifold cracked
Replies
0
Views
509
westcoast a3
W
Westy
XS Exhaust Manifold heat shield
Replies
50
Views
5K
liquids3
liquids3
IrishDave
Anyone had problems with XS/Relentless Manifold?
Replies
27
Views
5K
Westy
Westy
s3clarke
XS manifold down pipe and decat
Replies
6
Views
976
liquids3
liquids3
Top
Back