AH FabricationsVolks Autos
Results 1 to 7 of 7
Like Tree4Likes
  • 4 Post By sameatworld

Thread: s3 test drive down under

  1. #1
    Reverse Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Posts
    12

    s3 test drive down under

    Hi guys

    feel free to move this to another thread if appropriate.

    Just thought I would share what I posted on the ozaudi forum.


    The car was misano red S-tronic with performance pack which allowed me to re-evaluate the value of the performance package we have ordered. At the time of ordering, no one was aware that the magnetic ride could be optioned seperately for $1600 and hence we ticked the PP despite the annoyance of losing electric adjustment of seats. Now that you can option just the magnetic ride, I was having second thoughts.

    Here are some thoughts on the rest of performance package
    1. Super sport seats: They do look nicer and makes the car a bit more special over standard seats. But my wife really wanted the electric tilt of standard seats as she often reclines the seat when we are driving down to Sydney. She finds the rotary control difficult to turn and hard(!) work.

    2. B&O : Couldn't tell too much difference to the audi system to be honest but will probably need better set of music and time to appreciate. Both were significantly better than the crappy Golf R system. Hell, my VW UP!'s speakers sound better than the R's.

    3. LED headlights : Couldn't test them out as was daylight. I like the concept and the exclusivity of them but not expecting significant improvement over the already amazing xenons of R.

    4. Wheels and red brakes : Purely look related obviously but I'm not as big fan of the standard sline wheels. Standard wheels will prob need more frequent washing and I imagine more difficult to clean as well (but not as bad as the R's)

    Hmmm so worth the $3400 when you minus the magnetic ride from $4990? I'm still not too sure. The collectiveness of the above will definitely help differentiate the s3 from sline a3. But if funds are tight then will be first thing to get rid of. Anyway our collection is already a bit delayed so not keen on waiting even further by changing options now.

    What are my thoughts for the rest of the car? Nice is the word to sum it up really. I've previously had stg 2 MKV GTI and then stg1 golf R and now driving an UP!....

    1. Noise : As I've heard so much about the amazing new engine noise, I was fairly excited to finally check it out in person. To be honest, wasn't as distinctive as I was hoping. Especially compared to focus ST and SQ5 I've spent a fair bit of time in recently. It certainly was louder in dynamic mode than the R but nowhere near the loveliness of r32 or m135i

    2. Engine : Compared to the R, definitely had much more squirt earlier on in the rev range. Almost reminded me of MKV GTI with ECU and DP in the way it just picked up and went. Completely effortless and way way too easy to speed. Yikes!

    3. S-tronic : Wouldn't really expect it to be much different from the R and the pop between gear change wasn't as loud as the wake-up-the-neighbours bang of GTI with the RSC exhaust. I did notice that in dynamic, there was much less vibration when in 3rd gear as it normally does around 60kph in the R. Almost didn't notice that the car was in 3rd gear. I really liked the coasting function as well.

    4. Handling : went up and down a number of twisty roads trying to compare to the R. Definitely much less initial understeer that the R when you first turn in. In the R, you often account for the initial understeer then wait for the transfer of power for the R to pivot, grip and accelerate out of the curve. In the new S3, the turn in was just so much better that you can get on the power even earlier. Also noticed small lift off oversteer when you ease the throttle mid corner in a similar way to MKV GTI. This was something I missed greatly in the R.

    5. Steering : actually forgot to notice this aspect on the test drive.... I definitely can't remember experiencing much feel so I guess it's as what many motoring journalists describe. Thought it felt pretty similar to the R actually.

    6. Inside : NICE. I really like the simple and classy feel compared to the golf. This is one of the reason why I didn't consider the new R. The MK7 interior is fairly similar to the MK6 and we really wanted a nice place to sit in while doing the long weekend driving to Sydney and back from Canberra for 2014. Golf was nice but the new A3 is NICE.... lol


    Overall, I think the new S3 is an all round car. I consider a45, m135i and even golf R's much more "selfish" cars. I say that because they are cars I would get if I was the main driver and really wanted euro performance. The S3 will be my wife's car and also our long distance car. Hence I wanted it to be comfortable. In this regards, it's better than the a45 for us. I wanted an all wheel drive car, so even on rainy days, wifey can be a bit silly without scaring the bejesus out of herself (unlike the m135i... which I LOVE). Lastly, we wanted to move away from the Golf R and the number of times someone asks what you drive and you answer golf R, they then go "oh a golf ay? My younger sister has one.... (probably a tdi or something!!)". At least now my wife can just say she drives a small audi and that's that.

    Our car is currently week 5 build so still a long wait.... after the test drive my wife wanted one NOW.
    Last edited by sameatworld; 15th December 2013 at 04:18.

  2. # ADS
    ADS
    Join Date
    Always
    Posts
    Many
     
  3. #2
    Neutral

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Posts
    52
    Quote Originally Posted by sameatworld View Post
    Hi guys

    feel free to move this to another thread if appropriate.

    Just thought I would share what I posted on the ozaudi forum.


    The car was misano red S-tronic with performance pack which allowed me to re-evaluate the value of the performance package we have ordered. At the time of ordering, no one was aware that the magnetic ride could be optioned seperately for $1600 and hence we ticked the PP despite the annoyance of losing electric adjustment of seats. Now that you can option just the magnetic ride, I was having second thoughts.

    Here are some thoughts on the rest of performance package
    1. Super sport seats: They do look nicer and makes the car a bit more special over standard seats. But my wife really wanted the electric tilt of standard seats as she often reclines the seat when we are driving down to Sydney. She finds the rotary control difficult to turn and hard(!) work.

    2. B&O : Couldn't tell too much difference to the audi system to be honest but will probably need better set of music and time to appreciate. Both were significantly better than the crappy Golf R system. Hell, my VW UP!'s speakers sound better than the R's.

    3. LED headlights : Couldn't test them out as was daylight. I like the concept and the exclusivity of them but not expecting significant improvement over the already amazing xenons of R.

    4. Wheels and red brakes : Purely look related obviously but I'm not as big fan of the standard sline wheels. Standard wheels will prob need more frequent washing and I imagine more difficult to clean as well (but not as bad as the R's)

    Hmmm so worth the $3400 when you minus the magnetic ride from $4990? I'm still not too sure. The collectiveness of the above will definitely help differentiate the s3 from sline a3. But if funds are tight then will be first thing to get rid of. Anyway our collection is already a bit delayed so not keen on waiting even further by changing options now.

    What are my thoughts for the rest of the car? Nice is the word to sum it up really. I've previously had stg 2 MKV GTI and then stg1 golf R and now driving an UP!....

    1. Noise : As I've heard so much about the amazing new engine noise, I was fairly excited to finally check it out in person. To be honest, wasn't as distinctive as I was hoping. Especially compared to focus ST and SQ5 I've spent a fair bit of time in recently. It certainly was louder in dynamic mode than the R but nowhere near the loveliness of r32 or m135i

    2. Engine : Compared to the R, definitely had much more squirt earlier on in the rev range. Almost reminded me of MKV GTI with ECU and DP in the way it just picked up and went. Completely effortless and way way too easy to speed. Yikes!

    3. S-tronic : Wouldn't really expect it to be much different from the R and the pop between gear change wasn't as loud as the wake-up-the-neighbours bang of GTI with the RSC exhaust. I did notice that in dynamic, there was much less vibration when in 3rd gear as it normally does around 60kph in the R. Almost didn't notice that the car was in 3rd gear. I really liked the coasting function as well.

    4. Handling : went up and down a number of twisty roads trying to compare to the R. Definitely much less initial understeer that the R when you first turn in. In the R, you often account for the initial understeer then wait for the transfer of power for the R to pivot, grip and accelerate out of the curve. In the new S3, the turn in was just so much better that you can get on the power even earlier. Also noticed small lift off oversteer when you ease the throttle mid corner in a similar way to MKV GTI. This was something I missed greatly in the R.

    5. Steering : actually forgot to notice this aspect on the test drive.... I definitely can't remember experiencing much feel so I guess it's as what many motoring journalists describe. Thought it felt pretty similar to the R actually.

    6. Inside : NICE. I really like the simple and classy feel compared to the golf. This is one of the reason why I didn't consider the new R. The MK7 interior is fairly similar to the MK6 and we really wanted a nice place to sit in while doing the long weekend driving to Sydney and back from Canberra for 2014. Golf was nice but the new A3 is NICE.... lol


    Overall, I think the new S3 is an all round car. I consider a45, m135i and even golf R's much more "selfish" cars. I say that because they are cars I would get if I was the main driver and really wanted euro performance. The S3 will be my wife's car and also our long distance car. Hence I wanted it to be comfortable. In this regards, it's better than the a45 for us. I wanted an all wheel drive car, so even on rainy days, wifey can be a bit silly without scaring the bejesus out of herself (unlike the m135i... which I LOVE). Lastly, we wanted to move away from the Golf R and the number of times someone asks what you drive and you answer golf R, they then go "oh a golf ay? My younger sister has one.... (probably a tdi or something!!)". At least now my wife can just say she drives a small audi and that's that.

    Our car is currently week 5 build so still a long wait.... after the test drive my wife wanted one NOW.
    So pleased to hear from one who has driven an R and one of these. Sounds like we are doing it for the same sort of reasons. I love the R, but find the lack of grunt below 2000rpm a bit frustrating and the vanilla interior a bit disappointing. Looking forward to a few more toys and a bit more low rev spit and fire. Also had a MkV GTI prior to the R but no mods on any of these

  4. #3
    Banned

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    SW
    Posts
    2,353
    Are we talking new S3 and old R?
    The new R has same mechanicals as news S3 as far as I know!

  5. #4
    Neutral

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Posts
    52
    Quote Originally Posted by PilotAudi View Post
    Are we talking new S3 and old R?
    The new R has same mechanicals as news S3 as far as I know!
    For me an "old" R. 2010. The low rpm hesitation is the frustrating part. Once you have the motor singing it just goes, but needs 2400rpm to really start to pull. Has a different torque curve to the new motor.

  6. #5
    snakehips's Avatar
    3rd Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    North Herts
    Posts
    604
    Excellent report. I notice our wives/girlfriends generally aren't rated very highly on this forum in terms of driving ability! Is this just us asserting our manliness or are they really that rubbish?
    A3 SB S-Line TDi 184PS Quattro S-tronic. Shiraz Red, Tech Pack, Comfort Pack, B&O, Sunroof, LED lights, lots of other stuff.

  7. #6
    Banned

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    SW
    Posts
    2,353
    My wife is an excellent driver and looking forward to our new S3.. She has had a Quattro turbo 3 before!

  8. #7
    snakehips's Avatar
    3rd Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    North Herts
    Posts
    604
    Quote Originally Posted by PilotAudi View Post
    My wife is an excellent driver and looking forward to our new S3.. She has had a Quattro turbo 3 before!
    Yup, I know it's really just banter and I'm sure sameatworld's wifey is excellent too. I could never tease my wife for her abilities since I am actually too scared to drive her 370z - it's a monster but she loves it.
    A3 SB S-Line TDi 184PS Quattro S-tronic. Shiraz Red, Tech Pack, Comfort Pack, B&O, Sunroof, LED lights, lots of other stuff.

 

 

Similar Threads

  1. Test drive Alfa GT 3.2 24v
    By abmunro in forum General Chat
    Replies: 20
    Last Post: 28th February 2005, 14:37
  2. DSG test drive
    By _Steve in forum A3/S3/Sportback (8P Chassis)
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 12th January 2005, 21:59
  3. S3 test drive
    By FTO in forum A3/S3 Forum (8L Chassis)
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 9th July 2004, 16:49
  4. Performance Open Week - My Test Drive
    By PaulBelsham in forum A3/S3 Forum (8L Chassis)
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 9th December 2003, 13:25

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO

Garage Plus, Vendor Tools vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.

Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO