Badger5Sky Insurance
Results 1 to 18 of 18
  1. #1
    1st Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    Newcastle, UK
    Posts
    143

    S-Line 170 TDI or Sport 170 Quattro

    Madness perhaps, but despite it's faults, and the fact that I haven't been having to pick up the tabs (co. car), I'm thinking about another A3 (along with some other possibilities) when I'm due to choose a replacement in March `08.
    At the moment (our car lists changes twice a year) I could get an S-line 170TDi S-Tronic, or a Sport 170 Quattro. Unfortunately, CANT get S-Line 170 Quattro!!
    I've got the 140 sport with DSG at the moment, and although I do sometime find the `box a bit jerky in some conditions, and I still get the dreaded r/bout / junction lag if iI'm not careful, I think I'd like DSG again - I drive a lot for work and it's great NOT to have a manual when stuck in traffic or in rush-hour traffic etc.

    I would need to test drive both nearer the time, but like the look of and the spec level of the S-line, and I'm sure it'll be quick, but i wonder if the quattro 170 sport would make up for the more standard look and interior with superior grip & roadholding??

    Ooh, I'd even like Lava Grey AGAIN!! I just love the colour (when it's clean, which ain't that often!!).

    Anyone have any views?
    David
    09/04 - 07/08: A3 2.0 TDi Sport DSG: Lava Grey; Xenons.

  2. # ADS
    ADS
    Join Date
    Always
    Location
    Global
    Posts
    Many
     
  3. #2
    Phil's Barber's Avatar
    Top Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    89
    It's a tough call that one. One thing I can tell you is that the TDI 170 needs 4wd in the wet. My 170 A4 spins its wheels far to easily in the wet. Off course this may be less so on the A3 but I doubt it. Its a lot of torque to get down through a fwd chassis.
    A4 2.0TDI 170 S-Line. Dolphin Grey. Symphony II+, Bose, Int Light Pack, Centre Armrest, Cruise.

  4. #3
    SteveTDCi's Avatar
    5th Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Lincs
    Posts
    1,384
    If you spend time stuck in traffic then the DSG would be the way to go. But then if you drive on country roads quattro is the war to go ... with the DSG could you load it up for launches ? hold your foot on the brake and with it in gear put you foot on the accelerator, when theres a gap just release the breke ?

  5. #4
    Kris's Avatar
    1st Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Nottingham
    Posts
    220
    Quattro is about the only option i regret not having. My A3 170 TDI will spin the wheels in low gears in the dry and badly in the wet. Easy option is to ease the throttle on but there's times in the dry i want to have a play and ESP is kicking in. Could turn it off but would preffer ESP and qauttro.

  6. #5
    maars's Avatar
    Full speed ahead

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Posts
    567
    quattro every time.

    I drove a 140 2wd DSG and a 170 quattro manual (both TDI) and the quattro outclassed the 2wd every time. The 2wd's ESP was flashing away exiting a roundabout at speed (in the wet) whereas the quattro is virtually unflappable. Only once have I seen the traction control light come on and then I was pushing it hard. Day to day the quattro handling, dry or wet, is an experience not to be missed.

    And Lava Grey is the new black

  7. #6
    1st Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    Newcastle, UK
    Posts
    143
    Quote Originally Posted by SteveTDCi
    If you spend time stuck in traffic then the DSG would be the way to go. But then if you drive on country roads quattro is the war to go ... with the DSG could you load it up for launches ? hold your foot on the brake and with it in gear put you foot on the accelerator, when theres a gap just release the breke ?
    Not quite as easy as that also Steve, i live out in the sticks and there's a lot of twisty-bits, and also live 2 miles along a C-road, but then the last 4 miles of my daily commute to work takes me 20 mins in noes-to-tail traffic.
    Plus i'm usually out of the office traipsing on some motorway 1 day a week.
    I'd love the quattro, but I also love not having the "chore" of clutch operation when stuck in traffic.

    It IS going to be a tough one, and I don't think a test-drive in both cars will make my mind up.
    Pity the 3.2v6 ain't on my co.car list, but then again the torque of that is not dissimilar to my "little" 2.0 tdi 140....

    And you can't "load it up" on the gas with foot on the brake - i've been doing a bit of left-foot braking of late, but at low speeds foot-on-brake = power cut to engine.....

    And flipping a coin is no good - you dont get the answer you like the sound of so you go for "best out of 3" !!!!!!!
    09/04 - 07/08: A3 2.0 TDi Sport DSG: Lava Grey; Xenons.

  8. #7
    TDI-line's Avatar
    Uber Post Whore

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Peterborough
    Posts
    8,885
    Difficult one, can't your company update there list as there is only about 25 difference between the s-tronic and quatrro s-line?

    2013 AUDI A3 SB S-LINE : 2.0 TDIQ 184 : GLACIER WHITE :
    : S-TRONIC : COMFORT PACK : SD SAT NAV : FOLDING MIRRORS : HEATED SEATS: RIGID BOOT LINER :

  9. #8
    mcmasman's Avatar
    1st Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Norway
    Posts
    152
    Good choice on the paint! I have not regret getting Lava Grey, but i do find myself spending a bit too much time keeping it clean and shinny. Thing is though, when it's all done, the pearleffect really rewards you at the end.
    2007 Lava grey A3 2.0 140 TDI Quattro Sportsback
    S-line int/ext, cruise, mfsw, aluminum rails, Xenons+, coming-leaving home, light + rain, parking sensors, hill hold, Bluefin, 18" OEM double 7-spokes RS4 alloys

  10. #9
    1st Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    147
    From what you have said I think it's a lemon squeezy decision.... go for the Auto S-line. You'll get a whole lot more value from the DSG if you love the auto in traffic than you will from the Quattro which in all honesty I find kicks in very rarely.

    Not sure if its an issue, but you lose a not insignificant amount of boot space with the quattro.

    But please not another Lava Grey. I know you like it but you risk getting sick of it before you sell it. Have a change of colour just for something different. Anyway half the fun is flaunting the fact you've got a new car!

    Good luck and have fun pondering a very nice decision!
    A3 Sportback TDI 170 Quattro Sport
    A1 1.4 TFSI S-line S-tronic
    S4 Cabriolet

  11. #10
    Vertigo1's Avatar
    6th Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Posts
    2,624
    Firstly, why on earth can't you have an S-Line Quattro? It's the same price as the S-Line DSG!?

    Secondly, as this is a company car, be aware that the Quattro option will whack the emissions band up, which might be a factor for you.
    Daytona Grey Audi A3 2.0TDI 150 S-Line with Tech Pack, Comfort Pack, Interior Light Pack, Alcantara/Leather seats, B&O sound, DAB radio, Folding/dimming mirrors

  12. #11
    4th Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    West London
    Posts
    850
    Quote Originally Posted by roadrunner
    From what you have said I think it's a lemon squeezy decision.... go for the Auto S-line. You'll get a whole lot more value from the DSG if you love the auto in traffic than you will from the Quattro which in all honesty I find kicks in very rarely.
    The haldex unit is working all the time, have you driven a fwd 170TDI?. Its like chalk and cheese driving a fwd 2.0T compared to our Quattro one, it feels much more sure footed and ive never even seen the traction control light on yet.
    Now:BMW 530d M-sport tourer. Then:Lava Grey A3 Sportback S-line 2.0TFSI Quattro, S-line Special Edition, Xenon Plus, Leather, Light and Rain Pack, Interior light Pack, Bose, DVD Nav+, Bluetooth, Multifunction wheel,Cruise, Heated Front Seats, Folding Mirrors, Rear Parking Sensor and some other bits.

  13. #12
    1st Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    147
    Quote Originally Posted by Dandle
    have you driven a fwd 170TDI?
    With the number of times my vehicle has been off the road (including again right now) I've had the chance to drive several fwd 170 loan cars.

    Apart from wet/snowy conditions I haven't thought while driving them... I really miss my Quattro. Maybe with all the practice I've adjusted my driving technique and just got more used to fwd!

    Dave try them both before you make your mind up. Do let us know.
    A3 Sportback TDI 170 Quattro Sport
    A1 1.4 TFSI S-line S-tronic
    S4 Cabriolet

  14. #13
    Boydie
    Guest
    I havent read the thread but my 2p - 170 sline FWD

    do not ge quattro

    the quattro saps too much power from what i have been told

    the normal 170pd is much sharper but then again you could get a 140pd and remap it to 175/180 and it would still be quicker and cheaper than a 170pd

  15. #14
    Jos
    Neutral

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Lisbon, Portugal
    Posts
    33
    Had a few wild rides in a TDI140 DSG and it's great! Still good traction, nevertheless it can't put ALL the power down of course.
    I had to make the same choice myself early this year between the S3 and the TDI 170. If you're going to find lots of snow, and if you plan to drive really hard all the time that's quattro.
    you'll pay more cash, and since july so will we here in portugal due to the increase in CO2.
    If you're not fully committed to drive hard, then it's not worth it.
    The weather is quite worse in your country and quattro is always more safe, boot space has some reduction, but lets not consider that...
    Hope I gave some valid arguments to consider
    Last edited by Jos; 18th October 2007 at 00:24.
    S3' Apr 2007 - leather seats, silver, BT, Ipod, 18" 7 twin-spoke rims, flat bottom MFSW

  16. #15
    RGBArgee
    Guest

    Quattro every time

    Drive them both and decide. With loads of torque I think Quattro is the best!!

    2.0T Quattro !!!

  17. #16
    Amchlolor's Avatar
    6th Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Aberdeen
    Posts
    5,602
    As a DSG owner, I'd say you should go for quattro.
    '02 to '05 - Black Audi A4 1.9tdi sport
    '05 to '08 - Akoya Silver A3 sportback S-line DSG
    '08 to ? - Black Alpina D3

  18. #17
    1st Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    147
    Quote Originally Posted by bowfer
    As a DSG owner, I'd say you should go for quattro.

    But he'll get very fed up with stalling it in first gear!
    A3 Sportback TDI 170 Quattro Sport
    A1 1.4 TFSI S-line S-tronic
    S4 Cabriolet

  19. #18
    1st Gear

    Status
    Offline
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    Newcastle, UK
    Posts
    143
    Thanks for all the comments guys.
    Yes, test-drives are in order most definitely, but I have a horrible feeling that a couple of days (and many hundred miles!!) with each STILL won't give me a clear favourite......
    And to the questions re the car list - it's based on whole-life costs, which way the wind is blowing, the relationship between said car and a "theoretical reference model's costs in that grade", whether it's a shrove Tuesday, residuals, if there is a sacraficial goat handy, servincing etc etc.
    I COULD opt out -
    which would mean the bus!
    09/04 - 07/08: A3 2.0 TDi Sport DSG: Lava Grey; Xenons.

 

 

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO

Garage Plus, Vendor Tools vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.

Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO