[ QUOTE ]
How can you judge a hatchback against a saloon? Regardless of how good the 3 series is or not, they are not in the same playing field.
[/ QUOTE ]
Of course you can judge them between each other! Just because they are 2 different bodyshapes doesn't mean that you can't compare them - it just means that the prospective owner doesn't have a requirement for either style of car. If we were saying "Well I dont wan't an A3 because the bootspace is nowhere near as big as that on an A6 Avant" then there would be a point, but the cars are roughly the same value, so maybe the decision should be made on other specifics, like handling, fuel economy, performance etc etc.
[ QUOTE ]
1 series vs A3 - yes
[/ QUOTE ]
Agreed, on face value they would seem the obvious choice if looking specifically for a small hatchback, but as above if this is not an issue, and you don't like the look of the 1 Series (As a lot of people don't) then why consider it? Plus, JamesD is looking for a 1-2 year old model, as the 1 series has not been out long there won't be many on the S/H market yet, and those that are available will be at a premium price.
[ QUOTE ]
And looking at the current values they are selling for, I would say that Audi win them hands down on deprecation
[/ QUOTE ]
Agreed
[ QUOTE ]
One other thing to add to the pot is that every jack the lad, chav, drug dealer has a BMW. I have no aspiration to join them.
[/ QUOTE ]
LOL! Get your point there! But, that doesn't stop them being a good car none the less. If you can handle being tarred with the same brush as all the other BMW drivers, then it is a superb car, but if not then bear it in mind when choosing!