No bowfer your wrong. I had a manual TDI for a day and hated it for one reason alone - the amount of times I had to push the clutch down to change gear because of the short rev range, having always had petrol engines up to then. I then had a TDI with a DSG for a day and it was marvellous. Some months earlier I had a drive in an TDI A4 with the multi-tronic gearbox and liked the way that would look after the 1st and 2nd changes that come up quickly with a diesel when you pull away quickly say from a junction. The DSG behaved in the same way and it was just what I liked.
During my normal driving I use tip-tronic all the time unless I'm creeping in a traffic jam when I switch to D. In tip-tronic I nearly always let the DSG handle the changes from 1-2 and 2-3 when it reaches max revs in the lower gear. After that I normally do all the up and down changes myself using the lever or paddles except of course the change to 1st whenever I stop.
So I was well aware of exactly how the DSG would behave and it was that behaviour that convinced me to change to a diesel from my 4 previous manual A3 1.8T Sports.
I can see you point about the DSG not holding the max revs, but I personally would hate it if it did, unless of course it was driver selectable. That, of course, would give us both what we want. Perhaps one day...
During my normal driving I use tip-tronic all the time unless I'm creeping in a traffic jam when I switch to D. In tip-tronic I nearly always let the DSG handle the changes from 1-2 and 2-3 when it reaches max revs in the lower gear. After that I normally do all the up and down changes myself using the lever or paddles except of course the change to 1st whenever I stop.
So I was well aware of exactly how the DSG would behave and it was that behaviour that convinced me to change to a diesel from my 4 previous manual A3 1.8T Sports.
I can see you point about the DSG not holding the max revs, but I personally would hate it if it did, unless of course it was driver selectable. That, of course, would give us both what we want. Perhaps one day...