I went for the chrome surround version...
Even though I think that the 'smoked' surrounds are probably best suited to a black car (which I have), I want to retain some sort of OEM-look. I know the angel-eye sidelight kind of avoids that mantra, but I think that aspect impacts the OEM look overall less than installing the smoked-surround version. I think maybe it's because I see the car's physical aesthetics (including the design of the clusters) and the style of illumination it has (ie, the light that's produced, not what's producing them) as somewhat disconnected. Possibly because the lights aren't always on, and moreso in this case as when I have dipped/main beam on too, the angel-eye effect isn't as prominent.
...But having said all of that, it's simply a matter of personal taste I guess, and I can totally understand that others might not share my thinking on it.
I suppose I'll only know for certain myself how much I like them when they're actually installed; but I'll definately post when they've landed and are installed, and as I say, with some (hopefully) decent before-and-after photos...
Face-lift tail-lights to be installed first anyway, but I'm not taking them back out of the box until I've washed and polished her at the weekend! (The A59 was good and sticky in the heat last sunday and suddenly the heavens opened, meaning my little 1.6 looks (from the back at least) like it could quite easily have a 3.0 TDI lump in it!)
Take it easy,
Rob.